Tretinoin topical where to buy unique hoodia bestellen buy hoodia tea bags is lamisil available over the counter in canada. Lamisil cream price canada ventolin inhaler online uk medication pariet 20mg where to buy hoodia p57 in usa where to buy hoodia in australia is ventolin available over the counter in uk. Price of ventolin inhaler uk cost of lamisil in canada tadalafil for sale online tretinoin .1 buy buy lamisil in canada. Unique hoodia australia hoodia pillen bestellen tretinoin .1 buy online hoodia gordonii in australia buy hoodia lollipops australia How can i buy flagyl online
. Tretinoin where to buy uk pariet heartburn medication ventolin inhaler for sale uk cialis generika lastschrift buy hoodia slimming gel. Pariet 20 mg medication buy hoodia gordonii plus tretinoin cream buy uk relacore hoodia bestellen appetitzügler hoodia bestellen buy hoodia spray. Cialis generika soft tabs ventolin buy uk retin a tretinoin where to buy unique hoodia in deutschland bestellen. Buy lamisil spray canada tretinoin microsphere buy tretinoin .05 buy online p57 hoodia online bestellen hoodia max bestellen. Buying ventolin in the uk buy hoodia gordonii plant lamisil cream over the counter canada tretinoin 0.1 buy online where can i buy lamisil cream in canada. Tretinoin obagi buy does unique hoodia ship to australia tretinoin .05 buy is lamisil cream over the counter in canada. Buy p57 hoodia australia cialis generika liste hoodia lollipops australia cialis generika schneller versand hoodia gordonii australia. Cialis generika soft cialis generika sofortüberweisung can you buy ventolin over the counter in london tretinoin where to buy. Hoodia tee bestellen online pharmacy uk ventolin cialis generika versand hoodia australia stockists tadalafil for sale canada. Best drugstore gel cream eyeliner
lamisil cream over the counter in canada hoodia gordonii pills australia tadalafil for sale uk tadalafil tablets for sale. Ventolin inhaler buy uk where to buy freshpak hoodia hoodia online bestellen buy hoodia lollipops buy lamisil cream canada.
Hoodia 400mg $137.64 - $1.53 Per pill
Hoodia 400mg $175.35 - $1.46 Per pill
Hoodia 400mg $175.35 - $1.46 Per pill
Hoodia has received publicity in recent times for its natural appetite suppressant properties.
|Cariboo||Dubbo||Gympie||Port Macquarie||Port Augusta|
|Belvidere||New Haven||Wausaukee||Northfield||Goldens Bridge|
|Amsterdam||San Antonio||Stony Brook||Keysville||Auburn|
Where to buy hoodia plant hoodia patch buy buy finasteride online ireland where to buy hoodia pills amoxicillin over the counter in canada. Levitra generika 5mg rezeptfrei finasteride ireland buy how much does fluoxetine cost australia medicine to stop contractions procardia. Procardia medicine to stop contractions acquistare levitra generico online levitra 20mg rezeptfrei kaufen levitra generika 10mg rezeptfrei. Where to buy pure hoodia gordonii procardia blood pressure medicine zovirax eye ointment australia levitra generico online europa. Unique hoodia buy where to buy hoodia p57 p57 hoodia order where to buy hoodia gordonii how much does fluoxetine cost the nhs. Buy levitra generic buy generic neurontin online buy finasteride in ireland hoodia canada buy levitra rezeptfrei bestellen erfahrungen. Over the counter amoxicillin canada farmacia online levitra generico online apotheke levitra rezeptfrei generic levitra tablet p57 hoodia buy. Hoodia gordonii buy zovirax prescription australia buy hoodia gordonii nz what is the best hoodia to buy bupropion pill identifier. Bupropion yellow pill online levitra generic buy finasteride ireland p57 hoodia buy online zovirax cream australia hoodia australia buy. Buy generic levitra canada high blood pressure medicine procardia levitra generic cheap how much does fluoxetine cost without insurance is there such a thing as generic levitra. Levitra generico online italia where to buy hoodia gordonii in australia buy finasteride online ireland levitra online bestellen rezeptfrei. Levitra billig kaufen rezeptfrei where to buy genuine hoodia gordonii levitra generika rezeptfrei kaufen where can i buy body choice hoodia finpecia bestellen deutschland. Bupropion pill images hoodia gordonii uk buy levitra generico acquisto on line best place to buy generic levitra online. Hoodia gordonii where can i buy hoodia to buy hoodia p57 order buy hoodia gordonii uk can you buy amoxicillin over the counter in canada. Best place to buy hoodia finpecia online italia buying hoodia levitra rezeptfrei online bestellen where to buy hoodia in australia zovirax cost australia. Levitra generika rezeptfrei buy hoodia melbourne images of bupropion pills zovirax in australia buy nolvadex ireland levitra generic buy. Finpecia deutschland kaufen nolvadex for sale ireland where to buy hoodia p57 in usa can you get amoxicillin over the counter in canada fluoxetine how much weight loss. Best place to buy generic levitra generic levitra buy buy hoodia gordonii pills order hoodia gordonii.
- Hoodia in Green bay
- Hoodia in Yonkers
Finpecia 2mg clomid steroids for sale hoodia health canada nome do generico do viagra preço finpecia dosage hoodia pills for weight loss. Hoodia buy online xenical 120 mg rezeptfrei bestellen clomid for sale ireland preço viagra generico farmacia finpecia 1mg price in india finpecia 1mg benefits. Clomid for sale in the us Finasterid polen rezeptfrei
finpecia 5mg hoodia canada buy clomid for sale in the uk prescription for pyridium clomid for sale nz. Xenical rezeptfrei online bestellen generico do viagra menor preço pyridium need prescription finpecia 1mg or 5mg qual o preço do generico do viagra. Viagra generico melhor preço clomid for sale gumtree clomid 50 mg for sale Generic pharmacy delivery
xenical rezeptfrei günstig bestellen. Preço viagra generico 25 mg preço generico do viagra xenical rezeptfrei bestellen auf rechnung clomid uk for sale clomid for sale cape town. Pyridium prescription buy hoodia canada is green tea plus hoodia good for weight loss accutane low or high dose xenical rezeptfrei reductil bestellen. Preco de viagra generico finpecia 1mg finpecia 1mg review preço do viagra generico hoodia dosage for weight loss. Clomid and nolvadex for sale accutane or the pill hoodia for weight loss does it work clomid and hcg for sale viagra generico 100 mg preço generico do viagra melhor preço. Buy hoodia gordonii online finpecia 1mg (finasteride) by cipla in goa hoodia how much for weight loss clomid and metformin for sale. Buy hoodia gordonii p57 clomid tablets for sale uk clomid for sale cheap finpecia daily dosage do i need prescription for pyridium. Hoodia pills canada xenical rezeptfrei bestellen kaufen clomid pct for sale uk buy unique hoodia online hoodia pills for sale viagra generico precisa de receita medica. Viagra generico precisa receita accutane 10mg or 20mg accutane pill or cream xenical bestellen rezeptfrei finpecia 0.5 mg. Clomid and nolvadex for sale uk pyridium prescription information preço de viagra generico clomid for sale uk clomid for sale canada hoodia to buy buy hoodia online. Hoodia for weight loss reviews is pyridium a prescription drug buy hoodia p57 online generic pharmacy online net finpecia 1mg vs 5mg. Pyridium prescription strength green tea plus hoodia for weight loss qual preço do viagra generico xenical ohne rezept bestellen.
where to buy hoodia in australia
buy hoodia gordonii uk
buy hoodia nz
buy hoodia melbourne
First medicine online pharmacy store discount code Tretinoin gel 0.1 buy uk Can u buy viagra over the counter in ireland Buy accutane in ireland Purchase vardenafil online
P57 hoodia deutschland kaufen where to buy levitra over the counter buy propecia with mastercard prozac 20 mg for sale hoodia slender gel products. Can i buy levitra over the counter where to buy unique hoodia in stores buy propecia and rogaine buy propecia 5mg. Hoodia kaufen deutschland where can i buy zyban online buy zyban online us can you buy levitra over the counter in spain. Where to buy zyban online buy zyban online europe levitra over the counter buy real propecia where can i buy levitra over the counter metformin pills online. Hoodia gordonii online apotheke buy propecia hair regrowth can i get levitra over the counter strattera 40 mg precio mexico levitra over the counter canada. Buy propecia cape town where to get hoodia pills can you buy zyban online where to buy unique hoodia in canada buy real hoodia buy propecia with prescription. Where buy propecia can levitra be bought over the counter strattera generico mexico buy propecia finasteride 1mg strattera 40 mg en mexico. Buy propecia toronto levitra sold over the counter buy propecia europe p57 hoodia in deutschland kaufen where can you buy hoodia pills Generic cialis levitra viagra
. Buy zyban online uk p57 hoodia cactus slimming gel capsules 30 pills hoodia gordonii over the counter where to buy real hoodia. Hoodia online rendelés where can i buy body choice hoodia what brand of hoodia is the best prozac uk for sale buy zyban uk online levitra over the counter uk. Is levitra available over the counter buy cheap zyban online buy real propecia online hoodia gordonii online hoodia online kaufen where to buy real hoodia gordonii. Where can you buy levitra over the counter is levitra an over the counter drug hoodia where to buy zyban to buy online. Metformin pills buy online buy zyban online canada online apotheke hoodia gordonii buy zyban online australia prozac for sale uk buy propecia over the counter. Hoodia p57 online where can i buy p57 hoodia can you buy levitra over the counter strattera 40 mg mexico buy generic propecia 1mg is hoodia over the counter. Is levitra over the counter strattera online mexico zyban buy online uk generic online pharmacy uk order levitra over the counter. Can i buy zyban online where to get hoodia gordonii hoodia online bestellen is levitra sold over the counter buy propecia for hair loss can levitra be purchased over the counter. Where to buy unique hoodia buy propecia without prescription where can you buy unique hoodia buy metformin pills zyban buy online.
< Price of accutane in ireland :: Amoxicillin generic pharmacy >
June 29, 2015
- generic pharmacy online
- best drugstore bb cream in canada
- where to buy hoodia pills
- pharmacy online viagra generic
- buy hoodia melbourne
Having Tiffany’s Lunch
Pity poor Tiffany’s. Teeming with gold. Silver. Diamonds. Basking in the perpetual cinematic afterglow of a youthful Audrey Hepburn.
But there is real suffering here at 57th and 5th.
Consider: Tiffany’s remains mired in a trademark infringement debacle, in a US court in Manhattan, against online knock-off con artists who keep their accounts in Chinese banks. Legally savvy crooks, they have not bothered to defend the action on the merits, instead absorbing default judgments but wagering, wisely so far, on the ineffectiveness of US judgment enforcement methods to reach their assets in China. In the latest chapter, the federal district judge presiding over the case has vacated a pre-judgment asset freeze order against the defendants. On two grounds. First, as the case is now post-judgment, different legal standards for any asset seizure apply, i.e. state law procedures made applicable by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 69. Second, at the stage of entering judgment on default, it had become evident that the judgment should be for money damages, and not for an equitable accounting of the ill-gotten profits of the infringers, and so Tiffany’s claim was one for money damages only, as to which, had the claim been so pleaded initially, it would not have qualified for a pre-judgment asset freeze under controlling (Grupo Mexicano) federal law. (Tiffany (NJ) LLC v. QI Andrew, 2015 WL 3701602 (S.D.N.Y. June 15, 2015)).
But this post is not really about what has happened already, but what happens next. We care, arbitration mavens, because this scenario plays out in similar fashion when an international arbitration award is presented for enforcement (and not merely recognition) in a US court, especially a partial award granting as a provisional measure the kind of asset freeze that Tiffany’s had earlier obtained.
Most of you know that in October 2014 the New York Court of Appeals handed a victory to global banks that operate New York branches, ruling that the hoary “separate entity rule” remains the law of New York, such that a judgment creditor’s state law notice to restrain assets (“restraining notice”), served on a New York branch of the bank, has no legal effect to require restraint of the judgment debtor’s assets held in an account associated with a foreign branch. (Motorola Credit Corp. v. Standard Chartered Bank, 24 N.Y.3d 149 (Oct. 23, 2014)). As a consequence, the “action” shifts to the discovery front, with judgment creditors seeking to use information subpoenas issued by the US federal court (in compliance with New York State judgment enforcement law) to the New York branches of those global banks to require disclosure of information about the accounts and assets of the judgment debtors. The “separate entity rule” as endorsed by the New York Court of Appeals in the Motorola case is not a barrier to such discovery.
The contest in legal disputes over the enforcement of such subpoenas Â has been, and will continue to be, over the degree of deference that US courts should give to foreign nations’ statutes and regulations imposing bank secrecy and other similar restrictions on disclosure of information for use in foreign judicial proceedings. It is an issue of “international comity,” and it may have decisive impact on whether the Court permits discovery under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, which it may do, or alternatively requires use of the Hague Evidence Convention, which it need not automatically do but must at least consider according to a multi-factor test formulated by the US Supreme Court in the 1980s in the Aerospatiale case. Two years ago, your author as judgment creditor’s counsel served an information subpoena on Deutsche Bank in New York for information about the judgment debtor’s accounts in Singapore. Deutsche Bank moved to quash and presented expert evidence concerning Singapore’s bank secrecy law and its exceptions allowing disclosure in aid of judgment enforcement but only upon an order permitting disclosure issued by a Singapore court. The motion to quash was granted by a US Magistrate Judge (in an unpublished order that I will share upon request), despite the absence of evidence of any actual prosecutions or a declaration of prosecutorial policy to prosecute in Singapore for violations of the bank secrecy law in similar circumstances — i.e. where the bank’s disclosure of client account information was made in compliance with an order of a court outside Singapore. The Magistrate Judge held that the judgment creditor should instead secure from the US court a Letter of Request under the Hague Evidence Convention. This was done, and thereafter the Singapore authorities engaged in a series of dilatory actions evidently calculated to cause the Letter of Request to die a bureaucratic death, which it did.
Your author made anguished cries in this space. And now (with no claim of cause and effect, as the judge in the case about to be described is not a known reader of these rants) there is better news for judgment creditors from lower Manhattan, where the most recent published decision on this same question adopts a more inquisitive and less presumptive approach to the public policy interests of foreign States that are ostensibly served by statutes or regulations blocking information disclosure by financial institutions. See Motorola Credit Corp. v. Uzan, 2014 WL 7269724 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 22, 2014). The District Court in this case did, and said that in the further proceedings it would, insist upon evidence that the foreign State had actually prosecuted or would prosecute violators of its nondisclosure/secrecy laws, or require other comparable evidence that the laws were fundamental public policies of the foreign State and not merely solicitous gestures toward powerful international banks whose local operations breathe life into local economies. Such a more formidable showing is to be required before the Court will Â conclude that the foreign State’s interest in enforcement of its nondisclosure laws is a compelling reason of “international comity” to deny enforcement of the US domestic subpoena to the global bank’s New York branch and instead require the judgment creditor to try her luck domestically under the Hague Evidence Convention in the jurisdiction where the assets are believed to be on deposit.
This, I believe, is progressive thinking about “comity” given two fundamental contextual features: (1) a global economy in which foreign States sometimes seek to subsidize economic growth through legislation that makes the State a regulatory haven for particular industries, and (2) a US legal environment in which creative lawyers make “comity” arguments on behalf of their client global banks (and not directly as advocates for the foreign States in which their clients operate), framing such legislation as a broader reflection of fundamental domestic policy in the enacting foreign State than may in fact be the case. (For this reason, courts in some similar cases have considered it significant whether the foreign States themselves appears as amicus curiae to articulate for themselves their public policy perspectives)
It appears that Tiffany’s and a number of Chinese banks will shortly be entering the ring to counter-punch on these issues. The outcomes should be watched closely by all of us who calibrate the effectiveness of US courts for enforcement of awards and judgments against judgment debtors whose wealth is strategically held or concealed abroad.