Order imitrex from canada buy imitrex from canada is cialis a prescription drug in usa imitrex generic canada canada mail order viagra where to purchase imitrex in canada. Claritin d online coupon cialis prescription quebec cialis uk prescription xenical cost uk imitrex from canadian pharmacy. Amaryl medication diabetes buy prednisone online in uk cialis ireland prescription how much prednisone for child with asthma how much weight can prednisone make you gain. How much weight will i gain from prednisone Buy valacyclovir tablets
buy prednisone cream buy prednisone dose pack is cialis a prescription drug in australia. Buy claritin d generic online cialis non-prescription generic cialis how much is cialis prescription amaryl glimepiride medication. How much does prednisone cost without insurance xenical cost australia buy claritin online cheap buy claritin d 12 hour online is cialis a prescription drug. Cost of xenical in australia how much prednisone is prescribed for asthma viagra mail order canada buy prednisone 20mg tablets. Buy prednisone 40 mg buy prednisone overnight delivery xenical cost usa canadian mail order viagra claritin coupon online cost of xenical without insurance viagra canada buy online. Xenical cost in canada prescription discount card cialis viagra generic canada Zyban to buy online
buy prednisone canada amaryl medication wiki. Xenical online cost viagra in canada online prescription cialis quebec drugstore free shipping $25 buy imitrex online canada prednisone online purchase
. Xenical prescription cost viagra generic from canada xenical average cost xenical cost canada buy imitrex in canada buy prednisone 50 mg xenical cost ireland.
|Prednisone Rhinow||Erwitte||Buckow||Pfarrkirchen||Wittichenau||Wendlingen am Neckar||Neuss||Gießen||Goslar|
Prednisone 10mg $54.46 - $0.45 Per pill
Prednisone 20mg $54.4 - $0.6 Per pill
Prednisone 20mg $54.4 - $0.6 Per pill
Prednisone 40mg $126.48 - $0.47 Per pill
Prednisone 40mg $43.75 - $1.46 Per pill
Prednisone is used for treating severe allergies, arthritis, asthma, multiple sclerosis, and skin conditions.
- Buy cytotec online in usa
- Clomid mail order
- Viagra generika kaufen ohne rezept
- Buspar order online
- Online pharmacy canada free shipping
- Best drugstore lip liner uk
- Buy cytotec misoprostol online
- Orlistat tablets for sale
|Prednisone Bunbury||Kootenay Boundary||Prednisone Launceston||Charters Towers||Prednisone Fort St. John|
Can i order cialis online in canada drugstore makeup free shipping stop prednisone weight loss prednisone weight loss cats gabapentina bula preço. Levitra rezeptfrei aus deutschland levitra ohne rezept aus deutschland generic prednisone tablets tapering off prednisone weight loss. Order cialis online canadian pharmacy dexamethasone vs prednisone potency zoloft dosage morning or night prednisone pills online is methylprednisolone generic for prednisone. Prednisone weight loss dogs prednisone cause weight loss in dogs which is better for anxiety zoloft or effexor short term prednisone weight loss. prednisone online overnight
generic to prednisone prednisone moon face weight loss order cialis online us pharmacy. Cheap cialis pills online dexamethasone vs prednisone for ivf dexamethasone vs prednisone ivf levitra rezeptfrei in deutschland kaufen. Buying cialis online australia can prednisone cause weight loss cheap cialis online australia generic equivalent of prednisone. Which is better for weight loss wellbutrin or zoloft zoloft or wellbutrin for anxiety dexamethasone vs prednisone pediatrics. Is wellbutrin or zoloft better for anxiety dexamethasone sodium phosphate vs decadron polymyalgia rheumatica prednisone weight loss. Which is better zoloft or prozac for anxiety celexa or zoloft for anxiety and depression buy prednisone online from mexico
. Levitra kaufen deutschland prozac zoloft or xanax levitra kaufen schweiz gabapentina infarmed preço weight loss while on prednisone cialis discount prices online. Prednisone 5mg generic does cephalexin pills expire generic or zoloft prednisone and weight loss pills zoloft and weight loss or gain. Which drug is better prozac or zoloft zoloft dosage morning or evening oral prednisone for poison ivy or oak weight loss while taking prednisone. Zoloft cause weight loss or gain prednisone cause weight loss dexamethasone vs prednisone for cushing's syndrome Prednisone 20mg $54.4 - $0.6 Per pill
- Prednisone in San bernardino
- Prednisone in Arkansas
- Prednisone in Toowoomba
- Prednisone in Grand forks
Buy diflucan from canada new coumadin medicine how much does prednisone cost in australia buy cheap sildenafil citrate uk. Prednisone 3 pills at once coumadin skin necrosis emedicine purchase sildenafil uk Generic viagra and cialis
medicines to avoid while on coumadin. Buy zithromax in uk Generic brand topamax
buy gold max female viagra australia coumadin induced skin necrosis emedicine vitamin k coumadin reversal emedicine. Prednisone and weight loss pills coumadin blood pressure medicine where to buy gold max female viagra in australia. Buy valacyclovir generic buy diflucan online from canada buy viagra australia online cheapest sildenafil citrate uk where to buy viagra in australia. Prednisone effects on birth control pills prednisone price australia buying prednisone uk where to buy viagra sydney coumadin cold medicine interactions. Coumadin reversal emedicine prednisone buying prednisone 8 pills at once prednisone tablets 5 mg price Prednisone 20mg $45.67 - $0.76 Per pill. Coumadin and other medicines coumadin alternative medicine Sildenafil jelly uk
prednisone 10 mg price buy viagra cheap australia. Can i buy prednisone over the counter coumadin and allergy medicine can i buy diflucan over the counter in canada prednisone 1 mg price order sildenafil uk. Where to buy diflucan in canada prednisone where to buy coumadin medicine cost sildenafil buy uk prednisone 10mg tablets cost buy zithromax in usa. Where to buy viagra brisbane medicines to avoid when taking coumadin buy generic valacyclovir online buy zithromax in canada.
prednisone online overnight
buy prednisone online uk
prednisone online pharmacy
- Lowest cost viagra online
- Generic viagra cialis online pharmacy
- Phenergan buy australia
- Buy furosemide online australia
- Doxycycline hyclate online pharmacy
- Buy generic levitra online canada
- Amoxicillin 500mg price canada
- Can you buy amoxicillin over the counter in france
Pioglitazone 7.5 mg metformin glimepiride brands orlistat hexal online bestellen schweiz prednisone online overnight. Olmesartan amlodipine pfizer zetia medication for cholesterol where to buy orlistat in canada orlistat venta online buy prednisone online overnight. Buy prednisone online from mexico can you buy orlistat over the counter in canada lisinopril vs enalapril dosage buy metformin online cheap orlistat hexal online bestellen. Buy orlistat in canada lisinopril vs enalapril dosing orlistat farmacia online buy generic prednisone online order prednisone overnight amlodipine pfizer 5mg. Price for zetia at walmart buy prednisone online canada orlistat online canada can i buy orlistat in canada amlodipine besylate pfizer buy prednisone online australia. Alli orlistat farmacia online drug store skin care brands buy prednisone for asthma online orlistat kшb online buy pioglitazone generic brand for prednisone. Buy orlistat canada xenical orlistat online buy prednisone online with mastercard is prednisone a generic brand orlistat venda online. What is the generic brand for prednisone buy prednisone online in uk pioglitazone hydrochloride brand names. Where to buy cheap metformin buy prednisone online fast shipping orlistat buy canada buy prednisone online for humans amlodipine pfizer 5mg. Orlistat cheapest online buy metformin cheap get orlistat online orlistat hexal online kaufen orlistat gьnstig online kaufen. Can i buy prednisone online buy orlistat from canada buy prednisone online cheap lisinopril vs diovan blood pressure generic orlistat online. Lisinopril vs ramipril diabetes orlistat hexal online price for zetia 10mg olmesartan amlodipine pfizer orlistat online kopen. Best price for zetia buy orlistat online canada lisinopril vs diabetes Where can i order accutane online
buy prednisone online overnight price for zetia 10 mg. Buy prednisone online australia buy prednisone 5mg online where to buy prednisone online buy metformin cheap online Propecia 1 mg for sale
. Buy prednisone online uk orlistat buy online canada amlodipine 5mg tab norvasc pfizer buy prednisone overnight delivery dosage for zetia. Buy prednisone in the uk orlistat capsules online can you buy orlistat in canada orlistat online cheap amlodipine 5mg tab norvasc pfizer orlistat where to buy in canada. Price for zetia where can i buy orlistat in canada can you buy prednisone online norvasc amlodipine besylate pfizer orlistat shop online buy cheap metformin online. Alli orlistat vendita online buy prednisone 10mg online amlodipine besylate pfizer generic brand prednisone prednisone generic brand low dose vs high dose lisinopril.
free drugstore shipping
drugstore items free shipping
buy prednisone online uk
generic drugstore makati
prednisone sold online
buy prednisone online from mexico
prednisone pills online
drugstore free shipping
generic drugstore business
buy prednisone online canada
< Cialis from usa :: Cheap colchicine online >
April 02, 2015
The Strange Career of the Reasoned Award
“The Yankees win!! The….Yankees…..WIN!!!“
New Yorkers of a certain sporting obsession will recognize this as the triumphal incantation that concludes their radio baseball broadcasts, on the not-so-frequent occasions when the Yankees do, as they once did prodigiously, win.
New York arbitration lawyers will also recognize this as the form of a “Standard Award” in domestic commercial arbitration. Declare a winner, and sign off.
Those of you seeking a primer or a refresher course in the architecture of American arbitration awards would, by reading Tully Construction Co. v. Canam Steel Corp., 2015 WL 906128 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 2, 2015), be informed, or reminded, that here in the USA we have : (1) the Standard Award (“The Yankees win!“) (2) the Reasoned Award (perhaps not more than “The weight of the credible evidence shows that, after nine innings, the Yankees have four runs and the Red Sox only two!“), and (3) Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (wherein the arbitrator must actually think and act like a judge). As an historical matter, there have been relatively few domestic arbitrations wherein the parties demanded an Award in form of Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law as understood in the litigation process. Americans, as a rule, like their arbitration outcomes raw and lean. (And besides, as one reader has pointed out, it was thought that if the courts could not ascertain the basis for the decision, it would be more difficult for them to disagree with it).
The Tully case involved a dispute over steel components supplied to repair New York’s Bronx-Whitestone Bridge (a viable route to Yankee Stadium from Queens and Long Island). The parties opted to tear up their AAA arbitration agreement in favor of a non-administered process before a designated sole arbitrator using AAA Rules for Complex Construction Cases. Those Rules provided, concerning the form of the Award, for (1) “a concise financial breakdown of any monetary awards,” and (2) unless otherwise agreed by the parties, “a reasoned award.”Â The arbitrator, for his Award, provided the prescribed breakdown (by categories) of the monetary relief, and declared “Tully Wins!”Â When asked by losing side to withdraw this Award and provide a reasoned award, the arbitrator ruled that the awards was reasoned under all applicable state and federal law.
Not correct, held the U.S. District Court in Manhattan, granting a motion to vacate the award. From the Court’s decision, we are reminded that the “Standard” award, as a custom, evolved from early decisions holding that there is no federal common law principle requiring the arbitrator to state reasons for the result if the parties have not agreed that she should do so. We also learn that federal appeals courts have developed no uniform standard of what constitutes a reasoned award, and that district courts have allowed that it stands somewhere — and imprecisely so — between the Standard Award and Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law. In practical terms the “somewhere” is a large domain — the courts evidently recognizing that judicial second-guessing of the arbitrator on the sufficiency of the exposition of reasons collides with the objectives of efficiency and finality. But Tully was a case about the absence of any exposition of reasons — and by issuing a purported final decision not in the form specified by the arbitration agreement, the arbitrator was held to have exceeded his powers. The case was remanded to the arbitrator for re-issuance of the award in compliant form.
Tully provides an important reminder about the domestic arbitration culture of the United States. The “Standard” arbitration award is a custom associated with domestic arbitration’s roots as a streamlined alternative to judicial process. But it is ironic that the standard award and the minimally-reasoned award retain popularity with arbitration users despite the inundation of domestic arbitration with pre-hearing and hearing process associated with courthouse litigation. In Tully, the arbitrator heard 17 days of testimony from nine fact witnesses and two experts, and admitted more than 800 exhibits. The demand for Arbitration had been filed December 30, 2009, and the hearing began November 6, 2012 —Â so it is fair to assume there was an extensive discovery process. And yet the award took the form of a listing by categories of the amounts of monetary damages, essentially one page that mentioned no exhibits and cited no testimony. And still the arbitrator believed he had made a reasoned award.Â Perhaps both parties expected more, but once the result was announced only the loser really cared.
Award-writing seems not to be a skill that is particularly valued in our domestic arbitration culture. The AAA’s Procedures for Large Complex Cases do not require a reasoned award, much less findings of fact and conclusions of law, unless the parties insist.Â One rarely if ever sees, in the domestic setting, a provider-sponsored arbitrator training program focused on award-writing skills. The JAMS Arbitration Rules at least require, unless the parties agree otherwise, a “concise written statement” of the reasons for the award. One senses that JAMS’s instincts were toward more elaboration, but “concise” was adopted as anÂ acceptable limit beyond which JAMS could not go and expect to remain competitive with the AAA.Â The CPR’s rules for domestic arbitration, administered and non-administered, say only that the award “shall state the reasoning” — a standard that seems more permissive than a “reasoned award” and surely does not push the envelope beyond the forgiving standards applied by reviewing courts.
And yet the provider institutions purport to be responding to user tendencies to prefer adjudication in the court systems, doing so notably by creating procedures for appellate arbitration. Perhaps the time is ripe for reconsideration of rules concerning the content of awards, especially for the type of large and complex case wherein parties would naturally expect the discipline of writing an opinion to be a primary line of defense against erroneous decision.Â After all, how can the parties have confidence that the arbitrator has reached a correct result, or even that she paid sufficient attention to the massive record presented to her, if she has not completed the intellectual exercise of explaining her position in full written form?