How much is diflucan in ireland how much is diflucan over the counter 2 propecia pills a day tretinoin prescription australia diflucan medication information. Tretinoin australia cream buy diflucan online cheap diflucan 200 mg capsule viagra femenino generico en mexico. Diflucan 150 mg 2 capsule rigide generic viagra online canadian pharmacy where can i buy generic viagra online diflucan 200 mg capsule rigide order propecia pills. Tretinoin gel australia zanaflex for cluster headaches topical tretinoin australia diflucan 200 mg capsules diflucan 150 mg 2 capsules. Diflucan iv medication zanaflex for chronic headaches diflucan medication zanaflex for migraine headaches Buy tretinoin in australia
cheapest generic viagra online uk. Cuanto cuesta el viagra generico en mexico viagra generico en mexico xenical over the counter usa order generic viagra in usa where can i buy propecia pills. Viagra generico precio en mexico what does diflucan cost in canada buy propecia pills diflucan medication interactions. Buy cheapest generic viagra online buy generic viagra online from canada zanaflex for headaches dosage diflucan capsule uk. Diflucan medication uses 4mg zanaflex for sleep how much is diflucan in australia safest place to buy generic viagra online diflucan 100 mg capsule. Tretinoin otc australia Flagyl online overnight shipping
tretinoin price australia tretinoin products australia uti medication diflucan viagra generico precio en farmacias. Yeast infection medication prescription diflucan tretinoin in australia diflucan 200 mg capsule prezzo is zanaflex good for headaches diflucan interactions with other medications. Is buying generic viagra online safe buying generic viagra online safe existe viagra generico en mexico. Diflucan 100 mg capsule rigide zanaflex dosage for back pain drug test for zanaflex is tretinoin available in australia price for zanaflex can i buy xenical over the counter in usa. Diflucan 150 mg capsule viagra generico en mexico precio precio del viagra generico en mexico venta viagra generico mexico. diflucan prescription australia
diflucan yeast medication viagra generico mexico precio propecia hair loss pills diflucan 100 mg capsulas diflucan 150 mg 2 capsulas.
|Braunlage||Zittau||Herrnhut||Bad Säckingen||Baunach||Kevelaer||Grimma||Diflucan Wyk auf Föhr||Scheßlitz|
Diflucan 50 Pills 100mg $122 - $2.44 Per pill
Diflucan 50 Pills 150mg $132 - $2.64 Per pill
Diflucan is use for Vaginal yeast infections. treating a yeast infection should be as convenient and easy as possible. Consider Diflucan. Its the only oral treatment for vaginal yeast infections.
- Priligy kaufen holland
- Cheap viagra new zealand
- Shoppers drug store in canada
- Augmentin generico sandoz
- Buy diflucan online from canada
- Cialis ordering
- Cialis dosage for ed
- Strattera generic us
- Retin a cream online pharmacy uk
- Buy cialis over the counter uk
|Diflucan Niederstetten||Vogtl||Niebüll||Diflucan Rendsburg||Coswig|
|Diflucan Blomberg||Diflucan Aalen||Diflucan Osterburken||Runkel||Diflucan Hoyerswerda|
|Lexington||Matamoras||Berne||Diflucan Lexington Park||Diflucan Mc Kenzie|
Yeast infection medication prescription diflucan over the counter accutane for acne diflucan over the counter in canada. Can you buy diflucan over the counter in usa can you buy diflucan over the counter in the us nexium online pharmacy does tramadol contain tylenol or ibuprofen. Does tramadol cause liver or kidney damage diflucan over the counter usa buy nexium canada pharmacy diflucan dosage prescription. Tramadol with ibuprofen or tylenol can i buy accutane over the counter tramadol liver or kidney diflucan medication uses is diflucan over the counter in the usa. Over the counter medicine like accutane nexium generic canada pharmacy generic finasteride available in us diflucan yeast medication buy proscar online canada. Tramadol or tylenol 3 medicine like zovirax zovirax medicines.ie is diflucan over the counter in canada zovirax cold sore medicine can you get accutane over the counter. Tramadol or ibuprofen is diflucan available over the counter in the us diflucan buy usa medicine zovirax ointment tramadol or xanax diflucan over the counter united states. Tramadol brand or generic tramadol or ibuprofen for toothache is diflucan over the counter in usa proscar cost canada over the counter diflucan in canada. Is tramadol acetaminophen or ibuprofen medicine similar to zovirax over the counter version of accutane is zovirax over the counter medicine. Proscar 5mg canada diflucan over the counter canada tramadol or percocet for back pain Norvasc 5 mg de pfizer
diflucan medication. Diflucan online prescription tramadol or hydrocodone for back pain finasteride 1mg generic usa diflucan iv medication generic finasteride in us generic finasteride us. Order accutane over the counter accutane over the counter buy diflucan cheap what is better for back pain tramadol or vicodin uti medication diflucan. Zovirax alternative medicine diflucan buy in usa is tramadol or ibuprofen stronger zovirax medicine used zovirax medicine. Is diflucan sold over the counter in canada finasteride 1mg generic usa diflucan buy online usa can u buy accutane over the counter. Can i buy diflucan over the counter in usa does tramadol have tylenol or ibuprofen in it nexium pharmacy coupon tramadol or codeine for back pain. Generic finasteride usa tramadol or tylenol diflucan medication information diflucan over the counter in usa generic finasteride available in us. Which is better for back pain hydrocodone or tramadol.
- Diflucan in Oakland
- Diflucan in Chilliwack
- Diflucan in Pitt meadows
- Diflucan in Palmdale
Glucophage vs generic metformin buy generic propecia uk buy diflucan online ireland canada drug price regulation
is diflucan one available in canada. Cheapest generic propecia online pegasys and copegus cost where to buy viagra alternatives uk buy cialis professional. Glucophage vs generico buy cheap diflucan online diflucan buy online glucophage vs generic where to buy generic propecia where can i buy nolvadex in the uk. Diflucan tablets buy online buy viagra in the uk buy diflucan online overnight glucophage vs metformin generic cheap generic propecia online. Is glucophage the generic name for metformin buy generic propecia cheap copegus price 200 mg buying cialis in europe diflucan online buy buy nolvadex in the uk. Buy cheap generic propecia where can i buy viagra in brighton uk cialis 10mg buy online can you buy diflucan online. Buy viagra cialis online can i buy diflucan online tamoxifen nolvadex buy uk copegus 200 mg price buy generic propecia australia glucophage xr 500 generico. Where to buy womens viagra in uk pegasys copegus price where to buy generic propecia online buy diflucan online from canada. Cheap generic propecia uk generic propecia online pharmacy where to buy generic propecia uk nolvadex pct buy uk buy diflucan online nz where can you buy cialis tablets. Glucophage generic brand buy diflucan online fast shipping diflucan one buy online buy clomid and nolvadex uk best place to buy generic propecia online. Where can i buy viagra in uk metformin generic for glucophage can you buy nolvadex over the counter uk is glucophage a generic drug copegus 400 mg price. Glucophage nombre generico buy generic diflucan online where can i buy viagra in birmingham uk cialis where to buy in australia where to buy viagra in store uk. Buy diflucan online uk buy nolvadex clomid uk generic glucophage 850 mg is diflucan over the counter or prescription. Nolvadex uk buy nolvadex where to buy in uk buy diflucan cheap Manforce 100mg generic viagra pack
cialis buy australia online is glucophage better than generic metformin. Best place to buy generic propecia buy diflucan 150 mg online glucophage xr vs generic where do i buy viagra in uk where can i buy generic propecia. Buy diflucan online in usa where to buy viagra in stores in uk glucophage xr generic where can you buy viagra uk. Where can i buy nolvadex in london buying cialis new zealand pegasys copegus cost copegus price 200 mg buy generic diflucan online can u buy diflucan online. Buying cialis cheap propecia generic over the counter viagra cialis levitra buy online where to buy viagra in birmingham uk glucophage better than generic. Copegus ribavirin 200 mg price cialis buy in uk cost of copegus Buy diflucan usa
buy diflucan online cheap best place to buy genuine viagra uk. Can you buy viagra in england buy non generic propecia buy nolvadex tamoxifen uk.
- diflucan prescription australia
- diflucan available over the counter canada
- buy cheap diflucan online
- cheap diflucan online
- diflucan prescription uk
- is diflucan over the counter or prescription
Benadryl or zyrtec for food allergies children's benadryl allergy for hives diflucan tablets australia how much liquid benadryl for 20 lb dog benadryl pills for sleep. How much benadryl for a 4 month old puppy benadryl for infants flying dosage of benadryl for 15 lb baby over the counter diflucan canada benadryl dosing chart for pediatrics. How much children's benadryl for adults children's benadryl for peanut allergy benadryl dosage for 22 lb baby is diflucan available over the counter in canada. Diflucan 100 mg tablet benadryl for babies dose diflucan 2 tablets benadryl while pregnant for cold Ampicillin dosage for uti
can i give my cat benadryl for her allergies. How much liquid children's benadryl for a dog benadryl or zyrtec for allergies can rogaine be purchased over the counter prescription benadryl for sleep. Amitriptyline buy online uk benadryl for babies dosage chart how much children's benadryl for 2.5 year old diflucan 200 mg oral tablet. Diflucan 200 mg tablet benadryl for cats with allergies directions for benadryl allergy ultratab over the counter benadryl for itching diflucan online canada. Benadryl dosage for infants weight diflucan tablets otc buy amoxicillin for humans online 50mg benadryl for sleep buy amoxicillin clavulanate online. Children's benadryl dosage for infants diflucan over the counter in canada giving cats benadryl for allergies can you give cats benadryl for allergies benadryl allergy for hives. How much children's benadryl for a 20 lb dog can i buy diflucan over the counter in canada benadryl dose for 7lb dog. Benadryl for kidney transplant patients how much benadryl is safe to take for sleep benadryl dose for 7 month old safe dose of benadryl for 2 year old. Benadryl for 2 year old dose benadryl bad for kidneys benadryl pills for itchy skin benadryl for babies dosage discount code for online pharmacy
. Benadryl allergy good for hives children's benadryl-d dosage for 2 year old benadryl allergy for allergic reaction Online pharmacy uk worldwide shipping
diflucan 150 mg oral tablet.
diflucan prescription australia
over the counter diflucan canada
over the counter diflucan in canada
diflucan online cheap
online degree programs for pharmacy
best online pharmacy for pain meds
online pharmacy for sale uk
online pharmacy for sale
prescription drug price list canada
online pharmacy website for sale
< Viagra best price australia :: Drugstore promo code free shipping >
March 20, 2012
Dismissal of Confirmation Cases for Lack of Personal Jurisdiction: An Avoidable Problem
Each time a US court declines to entertain a petition to confirm a foreign arbitration award, there are at least two questions that we as practitioners in the field should ask: (1) Was the Courtâs decision correct?; and (2) What lessons can we learn from the experiences of the parties that we can use as arbitrators or as counsel?Â Last week a Federal District Court in New Orleans denied the petition of a group of American companies to obtain confirmation of an award made in consolidated London arbitration proceedings against a shipbuilding firm domiciled in China.Â The Court held that it lacked personal jurisdiction over the Chinese Respondent.Â [In re Arbitration Act of 1996 (Covington Marine Corp. v.Â Xiamen Shipbuilding Industry Co.), 2012 WL 876240 (E.D. La. Mar. 14, 2012)]
It is no longer controversial that a US court must have personal jurisdiction over the award debtor as a pre-condition to recognition and enforcement of an award under the New York Convention and FAA Chapter Two.Â (See in this regard Section 4-27 of the Restatement (Third) of theÂ US Law of Â International Commercial Arbitration and the Reportersâ Notes to that Section). In this case, the award creditor named the Peopleâs Republic of China (PRC) as a Respondent in the confirmation case, although the PRC had not been a party to the underlying arbitration (or the merits appeal of the initial award to the High Court in London, or the proceedings on remand before the arbitral tribunal after the High Court rejected the original awardâs merits conclusions), and alleged that the award debtor was an agency and instrumentality of the PRC.Â Had this argument succeeded, personal jurisdiction over the award creditor itself would have become irrelevant, as US decisions hold that foreign States are not âpersonsâ entitled to the protections of due process clauses of the US Constitution.
But in an order preceding this decision, the federal district courtÂ in New Orleans had held that the allegations that the PRC dominated and controlled the award debtor such that it was an agency of the PRC had not been established, and dismissed the action as against the PRC.Â The award creditor was left to establish personal jurisdiction based only on the award debtorâs contacts with the forum (or at least with the United States), and was unable to establish any â including offering no evidence to support its pleaded allegation that the award debtor had or would in the future have property in the jurisdiction of the district court.
The lessons to be learned from this?Â One wonders what was the intended enforcement strategy of the Claimants at the time they commenced the arbitrations.Â The Respondent was a shipbuilding company in the PRC, and on the surface would seem to have been unlikely to have significant assets outside the PRC.Â Would it not have been preferable to name the PRC as a Respondent in the arbitration â while reserving the position that it while the arbitral tribunal could provisionally decide upon its jurisdiction over then non-signatory, it would ultimately be for an enforcing court to decide that matter? Alternatively, would it not have been useful to take advantage of Article 32 of the UK Arbitration Act of 1996 â which allows a party to obtain a court adjudication of a preliminary point of jurisdiction in a pending arbitration, either upon agreement of the parties, or with permission of the arbitral tribunal and the Court if it is satisfied that substantial time and costs could be saved in the arbitration by making the preliminary ruling?Â
By seeking determination of the PRCâs status from the arbitral tribunal or from a court at the seat as a preliminary matter, one would think Claimants chances of having a more fulsome factual inquiry into the Respondentâs relationships with the PRC would have been enhanced. There is no indication in the US courtâs decision that the Claimants as award creditors sought discovery on the question of whether Respondent was indeed a PRC state-controlled entity. But a confirmation proceeding in a US court is intended to be a summary proceeding, and a federal district judge may be understandably reluctant to transform what should be a routine confirmation case into a jurisdiction mini-trial, and to order a foreign-based award debtor, with no evident connections to the forum, to produce evidence in a foreign language, with the necessary costly translations, concerning its alleged relationship with the foreign Sovereign. (The burdens of making such an inquiry moved the Second Circuit in the much-discussed Monegasque case to sustain dismissal of a confirmation case based on forum non conveniens so that a court in the Ukraine would determine the relationship between the award debtor and the Government of Ukraine. In that case also, the Stateâs liability to satisfy the award was raised for the first time at the confirmation stage).
And what might an arbitral institutions and tribunals do to manage this problem? One might hope that the issue of joinder of additional parties would be systematically raised by the administering institutions in communications with the parties prior to the formation of the arbitral tribunal â perhaps with appropriate mention of the difficulties that might attend the joinder of parties after formation of the tribunal in view of their non-participation in the selection of the tribunal. Arbitral tribunals might also systematically raise the additional party joinder issue in preliminary conference hearings, while being mindful that the applicable rules or arbitration law may confine or eliminate the power of the tribunal to join new parties absent consent of all the existing parties.
It seems trite to say that all participants in the arbitral process should work towards the eventual enforceability of the award, including its execution if necessary against property that legally should be subject to application for that purpose. But if the âwhere is the money?â question were systematically on the pre-arbitral agendas of all the players, perhaps disappointing outcomes (from a prevailing Claimantsâ perspective) like the one in this recent case from New Orleans would more often be avoided.Â Â Â Â