Pariet tablets what are they for kamagra pills for sale buy cefixime 400 mg Viagra generica rezeptfrei
kamagra 100mg pills pariet tabletas precio. Pariet tablets reflux acquisto cialis online originale kamagra oral jelly 100mg en france cialis originale online consegna 24 ore buy cefixime 400 mg uk. Pariet ec tablets 20 mg kamagra online france kamagra pills amazon buy kamagra france kamagra pills review avodart online bestellen. Kamagra polo chewable tablets uk ajanta kamagra 100 chewable tablet Kamagra 90 Pills 100mg $361 - $4.01 Per pill kamagra pills dosage. Cialis online sicuro in italia kamagra 100 chewable tablet valacyclovir hcl 1 gram tablet valacyclovir hcl 1 gm tablet avodart bestellen belgie buy cefixime 400 mg tablets. Valacyclovir hcl 1 gram tablets propecia generico españa pariet 10 mg tablets pariet tablets for ibs cialis online originale italia generic propecia in the united states. Kamagra soft chewable tablets kamagra soft tabs chewable tablets pariet tabletas 20 mg buy cefixime online kamagra polo chewable tablets. Kamagra pills wikipedia propecia generic 5mg pariet gastro resistant tablets acquistare cialis online in italia kamagra pills india pariet tablets used for. Cialis originale on line italia kamagra pills valacyclovir 1gm tablets price kamagra 100 chewable tablet einnahme kamagra sildenafil 32 pills buy cefixime online usa. Pariet ec tablet 20mg is propecia available in generic cialis originale online in italia kamagra chewable tablets uk cheap generic viagra co uk french kamagra. Pariet tablets for reflux pariet tablet uses cheap kamagra pills uk valacyclovir 1 g oral tablet propecia generic pricing kamagra 100mg chewable tablet. Pariet tablets when to take pariet tablets ingredients pariet tablets symptoms kamagra 100mg soft tabs chewable tablets cost of pariet tablets. Kamagra chewable tablets review kamagra bestellen per überweisung
|Henderson||Lewis Center||La Norah||Hooper||Bode||Morris||Kamagra Fawn Grove||Eastchester||Prospect|
Kamagra 30 Pills 100mg $121 - $4.03 Per pill
Kamagra 30 Pills 100mg $121 - $4.03 Per pill
Kamagra 40 Pills 100mg $161 - $4.03 Per pill
Kamagra 60 Pills 100mg $241 - $4.02 Per pill
Kamagra 80 Pills 100mg $321 - $4.01 Per pill
Kamagra 90 Pills 100mg $361 - $4.01 Per pill
SILDENAFIL - ORAL (sill-DEN-uh-fil) COMMON BRAND NAME(S): Kamagra. This medication is used to treat male sexual function problems (erection problems).
- Purchase viagra in new zealand
- Xenical chemist australia
- Valacyclovir generic for sale
|Dormagen||Velburg||Oppenau||Bergisch Gladbach||Isny im Allgäu|
|Duarte||Kamagra Long Prairie||Rutledge||Delafield||Smyrna|
Cialis soft tabs rezeptfrei accutane available in uk kamagra jelly bestellen belgie
amoxicillin fr katzen online kaufen generic cialis soft tabs 20mg. Kamagra oral jelly contents cialis soft tabs avis purchase amoxicillin online uk cialis soft tabs 20mg kaufen cialis soft tabs einnahme. Accutane prices uk cialis soft tabs kaufen cialis soft tabs ohne rezept accutane uk buy amoxicillin cheap online kamagra zollfrei bestellen. Order zovirax online kamagra oral jelly dosage cialis soft tabs bestellen cialis soft tabs wirkung cialis soft tabs preisvergleich. Cheap kamagra oral jelly accutane uk online Buying viagra in australia over the counter
amoxicillin buy online canada celebrex over the counter or prescription. Purchase cheap cialis soft tabs what is cialis soft tabs cialis soft tabs 40mg cialis soft tabs erfahrung amoxicillin shop online celebrex or ibuprofen for back pain. Valium over the counter canada accutane acne uk online pharmacy uk accutane accutane cost in uk kamagra in holland bestellen kamagra oral jelly 7 pack. Accutane uk prescription buy amoxicillin online overnight shipping erfahrungen mit cialis soft tabs buy valium from canada cialis soft tabs dosage. Amoxicillin 250 mg buy online amoxicillin sale online kamagra bestellen per telefon amoxicillin capsules online amoxicillin online kaufen kamagra bestellen zoll. Accutane uk cost kamagra oral jelly dose buy amoxicillin online next day delivery uk buy amoxicillin liquid online kamagra oral jelly does it make you last longer. Accutane procedure uk valium buy canada kamagra oral jelly melbourne cialis soft tabs 20mg erfahrungen cialis soft tabs online. Kamagra bestellen met visa accutane uk price amoxicillin buy online uk buy amoxicillin 500mg online uk. Cialis generic soft tabs no brasil cheap cialis soft tabs kamagra bestellen met mastercard buy amoxicillin 500 online kamagra bestellen aus holland. Suhagra 50 buy online
getting accutane in uk amoxicillin buy online usa accutane online pharmacy uk kamagra 100mg oral jelly dosage. Get amoxicillin online uk cialis soft tabs teilen accutane in uk accutane online uk buy amoxicillin online mexico amoxicillin online buy. Kamagrafast2 coupon kamagra oral jelly manchester can i order zovirax online generic cialis soft tabs kamagra oral jelly make you last longer. Kamagra telefonisch bestellen kamagra 100mg bestellen cialis soft tabs generico unterschied cialis und cialis soft tabs cheapest kamagra jelly. Kamagra fast coupon zovirax online order cialis soft tabs canada kamagra bestellen mit überweisung kamagra cialis bestellen buy amoxicillin online overnight. Amoxicillin 250 mg online kamagra oral jelly bulk cost of accutane privately uk.
- Kamagra in Bunbury
- Kamagra in Del.
- Kamagra in Fontana
- Kamagra in Nevada
- Kamagra in Mass.
- Kamagra in La trobe
Dulcolax safe dose range dulcolax oral reviews dulcolax tablets 5mg bisacodyl dulcolax 05 mg dulcolax oral liquid. Kamagra online aus deutschland dulcolax bisacodyl tablets 5mg dosage buy viagra kamagra uk dulcolax 10 mg suppositories. Kegunaan dulcolax bisacodyl 10 mg buy kamagra in london kamagra oral jelly kaufen deutschland metformin alternatives uk fungsi dulcolax bisacodyl 5 mg. Amitriptyline price canada
dulcolax max daily dose dulcolax dosage strength buy kamagra england dulcolax 5mg tablets dosage kamagra oral jelly 100mg deutschland. Dulcolax dosage for colonoscopy dulcolax 5mg dulcolax 5 mg dose metformin and clomid uk metformin uk prescription. Dulcolax stool softener oral reviews dulcolax tablets dosage colonoscopy kamagra rezeptfrei in deutschland. Dulcolax 2.5mg dosage kamagra aus deutschland bestellen kamagra oral jelly kaufen.at dulcolax dosage information dulcolax suppository dose for infants. Dulcolax dosage and administration kamagra oral jelly eu apotheke buy cheapest kamagra uk dulcolax dosage rxlist dosage of dulcolax 5mg cost of metformin in uk. Kamagra aus deutschland kaufen buy sildenafil in ireland metformin brands uk dulcolax dosage bowel prep dulcolax 5mg dosage instructions wo kann ich kamagra in deutschland kaufen. Dulcolax dosage 100mg Prednisone 10mg dose pack price
metformin in the uk metformin patient co uk dulcolax oral tablet dosage kamagra billig kaufen deutschland. Where to buy viagra in honolulu dulcolax 5mg dosage kamagra oral jelly in apotheke buy kamagra soho london. Dulcolax 100 mg dosage dulcolax 5mg tablets 200 dulcolax suppository maximum dosage where to buy viagra in hawaii metformin spc uk dulcolax maximum dosage. Dulcolax 50 mg dulcolax laxative tablets 5mg metformin and antipsychotics uk dulcolax tablets 5mg gastro-resistant.
kamagra bestellen in deutschland
kamagra jelly ireland
kamagra jelly günstig kaufen
kamagra oral jelly original bestellen
kamagra jelly günstig bestellen
kamagra 100mg oral jelly günstig kaufen
Buy citalopram hydrobromide online | Where can i buy viagra pills | Finasterid stada 1 mg filmtabletten | Sildenafil generico 50 mg precio
How do i buy amoxicillin online
finasteride drug tier can you order valtrex online gabapentin ed erezione kamagra jelly wo bestellen Cheap ventolin online
. Finasteride drug card drugs that interact with finasteride kamagra online bestellen ohne rezept zovirax pills for sale finasteride drug group finasteride drug insert. Valtrex order online order valtrex online usa proventil hfa discount card kamagra bestellen aus deutschland
finasteride drug action. Where to order valtrex online how can i order valtrex online cheapest price for kamagra finpecia new zealand kamagra 100mg oral jelly for sale. Drug finasteride 5mg kamagra wo bestellen erfahrungen kamagra for sale in the uk kamagra online bestellen deutschland kamagra gel for sale uk finasteride drug for hair loss. Hair loss drug finasteride valtrex online order kamagra bestellen erfahrungen kamagra for sale manchester is finasteride a prescription drug. Is finasteride a generic drug kamagra for sale cape town finasteride fixed drug eruption prescription drugs finasteride. Finasteride drug bank gabapentin and erectile dysfunction proventil discount card finasteride prostate drug prostate cancer drug finasteride. Finasteride drug cost proventil discount finasteride drug price finasteride 5mg drug what is the generic drug for finasteride. Kamagra gel online bestellen finasteride london drugs finasteride drug what is the cost of the drug finasteride.
< Where to buy over the counter tretinoin :: Super kamagra deutschland bestellen >
April 02, 2015
- kamagra 100mg oral jelly günstig kaufen
- generic drugstore website
- generic drugstore online
- kamagra bestellen in deutschland
- gamot publiko generic drugstore franchise
- generic drugstore franchise
- generic drugstore branches
- generic drugstore job hiring
- generic drugstore hiring
Bifurcated Arbitration and Interlocutory Review: Once More to the Well
Dear Readers, if you turned to these pages to learn about recent decisions in big, impactful international investment disputes over (lawful) expropriation of maritime assets in Venezuela or (alleged) denial of justice to American energy titans in Ecuador, you may be disappointed. (But see “Nice Try Venezuela”, below). This post is inspired by a gritty quotidian domestic dispute, between a Miami limousine service and one of its drivers — the cherubic talkative type who might ferry an eminent international arbitrator to Miami International Airport for an early morning flight to Washington.
But seriously. We need to talk — about the eligibility of interlocutory awards for confirmation or vacatur under the Federal Arbitration Act. Perhaps there will be readers on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, whose three-judge panel decided Schatt v. Avventura Limousine & Transp. Service, Inc., 2015 WL 1134910 (11th Cir. Mar. 16, 2015).
The Avventura arbitration, under AAA Commercial Rules, involved claims under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) asserting that the Claimant was an employee protected by the FLSA and had been compensated less fairly than the Act requires. The position of Respondent (theÂ putative employer) was that Claimant was not an employee but only an independent contractor to whom the FLSA did not apply. This liability issue, i.e. whether the FLSA applied at all, was bifurcated, evidently by agreement of the parties and with consent of the arbitrator. In an “Interim Award on Liability,” the arbitrator decided that Claimant was an employee, and she set in motion a damages phase of the case. Thereafter, the U.S. District Court in Miami granted a motion to disqualify Claimant’s counsel based on improper contacts with Respondent during the arbitration, contacts found to have been calculated to undermine the effectiveness of Respondent’s counsel. The District Court also received Respondent’s motion to vacate the Interim Award on Liability, and ruled that (1) the award was sufficiently final to be subject to review under the FAA, and (2) based on the same circumstances that warranted disqualification of counsel, the award had been “procured by fraud, corruption, or undue means” (FAA Â§ 10 (a) (1)) and therefore should be vacated. In Avventura, the Eleventh Circuit reversed on the basis that the Interim Award was non-final and therefore the District Court lacked power to apply the FAA grounds for vacatur.
At least in part because Respondent did not submit a brief, the Eleventh Circuit in Avventura did not consider case law from other Circuits that permits FAA review of arbitration awards that do not end the arbitration in at least three circumstances:
1) an award of provisional relief, where judicial enforcement of the award is necessary for the provisional measures to be effective,
2) an award that fully resolves a separate and independent claim within the arbitration,
3) an award that finally determines liability, where the parties have agreed to the bifurcation of the arbitration into liability and damages phases.
The Avventura award appears to have qualified for FAA review under Category 3.Â But the Court did not evidently find thatÂ case law in its own research, and adopted what we may call the Anti-Schubert Rule: no Unfinished Symphonies.Â The Court treated “final[ity]” in the FAA as a literal concept, and held that an award is not final when “the arbitrator’s work [is] not complete.”
The Eleventh Circuit will undo its Anti-Schubert Rule in due course, we may reasonably predict. My concern is, more broadly, with Category 3, concerning bifurcated arbitrations, and why it is (or is not) necessary for there to be an express agreement of the parties to bifurcate, made during the arbitration, as a precondition of FAA review of a partial award on liability.
The reason given by courts for assigning importance to the parties’ agreement to bifurcate (as originally stated by the Second Circuit in the Trade & Transport case in 1991, and repeated by the First Circuit in the Hart Surgical case in 2001) was that such agreement provided assurance to the courts that the parties and arbitrators understood during the arbitration that the award on the bifurcated issue (usually liability) would be final and binding and that the arbitrator would be functus officio with respect thereto. But if the rules of arbitration adopted by the parties provide for partial and interim as well as final awards, and provide that all such awards shall be final and binding on the parties, and provide that awards may only be modified by arbitrators to correct clerical errors, isn’t is fair to say that the power of the arbitrator to make a partial award that has sufficient finality to be judicially reviewable is built into the agreement to arbitrate? (The final and binding status of any award the tribunal might issue is clear in, for example, the arbitration rules of the ICDR, ICC, and UNCITRAL, and in the 2010 JAMS Comprehensive Arbitration Rules; the AAA Commercial Rules are less clear but the same conclusion is inferrable). Arguably, the existence or not of an explicit bifurcation agreement made during the arbitration should only matter if the rules governing the arbitration leave uncertainty about the ability of the arbitrator to reconsider, and reverse or modify substantively, an interlocutory decision called an “award.”
In the future courts may wish to consider whether an agreement of the parties to bifurcate liability and damages, or to bifurcate the arbitration in some other fashion that entails multiple awards, ought to be the necessary predicate for a court to decide that a partial or interim award is reviewable.Â “Finality” under the FAA is not defined precisely, and so it should be determined pragmatically. Absent other indications of what the parties intended, or expected, core principles underlying the FAA would suggest that the finality of an award that leaves some issues still open should be determined according to (1) the arbitrator’s indicated intention that the decision resolves a matter permanently and irreversibly, not temporarily or provisionally, (2) the importance of immediate review to the effectiveness of the arbitral decision, and (3) whether review is more likely to advance the completion of the arbitration or, at the opposite pole, disrupt the case with piecemeal review.
If the parties did not agree to bifurcation, but instead had bifurcation imposed by the arbitrator(s), the absence of agreement should not necessarily determine that a partial award on liability lacks jurisdictional eligibility to be confirmed or vacated. This circumstance instead requires courts to make record- and context- specific pragmatic judgments about the virtue or vice of interlocutory review. Â Suppose the arbitration is conducted under a provider’s rules that permit (as nearly all do) partial and interim awards and contain no limits on arbitrator discretion to bifurcate. Bifurcation of liability and damages is sought by Claimant, opposed by Respondent, and granted by the arbitrators in an early procedural order that states expressly the Tribunal’s intention that the liability phase will culminate in a partial award on liability that finally determines liability and leaves the Tribunal functus officio as to liability, and will be, as far as the Tribunal is concerned, subject to judicial review. Suppose further that the prospective virtue or vice of interlocutory review was clearly argued to the Tribunal in the motion to bifurcate. If the Tribunal after hearing the liability phase of the case follows through with a partial award on liability, the Tribunal’s judgment that interlocutory review provides more virtue than vice should be respected by the court absent some compelling countervailing consideration relating to the arbitral process.