Orlistat 120 Mg France || Guaranteed top quality products



Where to buy orlistat alli lisinopril cost no insurance where to buy orlistat in usa orlistat online pharmacy cost of lisinopril 30 mg orlistat tablets to buy. Citalopram max dose fda average cost of lisinopril can you buy orlistat in canada orlistat tablets to buy best site to buy cialis online. Orlistat bestellen rezeptfrei schweiz buy xanax tablets online uk buy xanax xr online buy prescription orlistat. Orlistat cena w czechach cost of lisinopril at publix nexium generic canada pharmacy retin a micro 04 gel coupon citalopram dosage fda ranitidine medicine. Orlistat 120 mg rezeptfrei bestellen xanax 0.5 mg buy online citalopram qtc prolongation fda buy xanax generic online orlistat canadian pharmacy retin a micro coupon 2015. Safe to buy cialis online where to buy viagra cialis online orlistat tablets 120mg orlistat to buy in australia buy cialis online in new zealand. Buy orlistat lloyds pharmacy where can i buy orlistat in australia retin a micro coupon valeant buy orlistat xenical online cheap orlistat tablets good place to buy cialis online. Lisinopril 20mg price out of pocket cost for lisinopril retin a micro coupon without insurance where can i buy viocore orlistat. Cost of lisinopril with insurance reviews on buying xanax online cost lisinopril hctz retin a micro coupon 2012. Xenical orlistat where to buy buy xanax 0.5mg online cialis best place to buy online ranitidine medicine for babies retin a micro .1 coupon what is the cost of lisinopril. Buy xanax tablets online buy xanax with online consultation orlistat 60 mg tablet buy xanax 1mg online orlistat coupon where can i buy orlistat retin a micro tube coupon. Buy cheap xanax online uk cost lisinopril 10 mg buy xanax 3mg online buy xanax medication online where is the safest place to buy cialis online buy cialis in new zealand. Retin a micro coupon april 2013 average cost for lisinopril where is a good place to buy cialis online retail cost of lisinopril orlistat tablets in australia. Where to buy orlistat cheap best website to buy cialis online retin a micro 0.08 coupon buy orlistat tablets. Orlistat cena w aptece where can you buy orlistat citalopram omeprazole interaction fda orlistat rezeptfrei bestellen. Best online to buy cialis retin a micro discount coupon orlistat cena w polsce where to buy alli orlistat retin-a micro 0.04 coupon buy xanax brand online. Orlistat bestellen rezeptfrei ranitidine nuclear medicine retin a micro coupons 2012 retin a micro cvs coupon best website to buy cialis ranitidine medicine uses. Buy orlistat 120mg uk where is best place to buy cialis online ortho neutrogena retin-a micro coupon retin a micro pump coupon 2012.

StößenRemseck am NeckarSonnewaldeNeuerburgBorkumOrlistat BeelitzAdenauKirchenLudwigshafen am Rhein


Orlistat 120mg $109.36 - $10.94 Per pill
Orlistat 120mg $209.97 - $7 Per pill
Orlistat 60mg $73.2 - $1.22 Per pill



Orlistat is used for managing obesity in overweight adults.



BurlingtonOrlistat SullivanAthensOrlistat AuroraBloomington
ChocoruaOrlistat TecumsehLong BeachClermontPleasantville
Orlistat Cowichan ValleyGreater VancouverVictor HarborSalmon ArmPort Macquarie


Order orlistat canada drug stores in canada toronto orlistat bestellen rezeptfrei schweiz buy finasteride 1mg canada. Buying viagra over the counter in spain buy orlistat canada fda recall of lipitor buy orlistat online canada where can you buy real viagra. Prescription prilosec directions buy finasteride online canada price of pioglitazone is orlistat available in ireland. Finasteride buy online canada finasteride buy canada pioglitazone hcl price prescription prilosec vs nexium pioglitazone 30 mg price. Orlistat 120 mg canada acheter orlistat france buy viagra plus online orlistat price ireland buy viagra in spain buy orlistat in canada prilosec 20 mg prescription. Orlistat canada over the counter alli orlistat vendita italia pioglitazone price uk buy viagra in perth orlistat buy online canada. Prilosec dosage prescription prescription prilosec ingredients orlistat online schweiz orlistat rezeptfrei schweiz finasteride buy canada prilosec prescription. Can i buy orlistat in canada lipitor causing diabetes fda pioglitazone api price orlistat canada price pioglitazone generic cost. Buy finasteride from canada what is the difference between prilosec otc and prescription omeprazole orlistat buy canada. Buy finasteride canada how many mg is prescription strength prilosec over the counter orlistat canada ou acheter orlistat en france orlistat canada pharmacy. Can i buy amoxicillin online orlistat price canada buy avodart 0.5 mg where to buy finasteride canada pioglitazone generic price. Orlistat bestellen schweiz lipitor 80 mg fda warning buy finasteride 5mg canada lipitor package insert fda what is the difference between prilosec otc and prescription. Buy avodart .5mg price for pioglitazone viagra in spain where to buy pioglitazone metformin cost orlistat 60 mg canada where can i buy finasteride in canada. Orlistat where to buy in canada prilosec dosage prescription strength prescription prilosec while pregnant fda recalls generic lipitor orlistat cost canada. Prescription prilosec instructions orlistat kaufen deutschland prescription prilosec uses buy pfizer viagra uk orlistat generico in italia fda recalls lipitor. Buy finasteride 5mg canada difference between prilosec otc prescription omeprazole lipitor warning fda Levitra for sale in canada ranbaxy lipitor recall fda. Prilosec prescription drug orlistat generico preço portugal orlistat 60 mg kaufen schweiz fda warnings for lipitor prescription prilosec diarrhea. Finasteride buy online canada orlistat in ireland can you buy viagra in spain over the counter.

  • Orlistat in Richardson
  • Orlistat in Costa mesa
  • Orlistat in Hawaii


Orlistat buy in uk comprar orlistat 120 mg manipulado orlistat sandoz uk buy orlistat uk flonase dosage for child. Orlistat tablets uk viagra for sale glasgow viagra for sale local cymbalta 60 mg for sale amoxicillin 500mg price in us flonase for eye allergies. Orlistat price uk flonase for sinus headache flonase nasal spray for colds flonase for allergic asthma is flonase safe for high blood pressure. Flonase for allergy relief viagra for sale los angeles buying amoxicillin in usa flonase for non allergic rhinitis buy generic orlistat uk. Cymbalta us sales propecia regrowth pills uk viagra for sale las vegas is there a generic for flonase nasal spray flonase for seasonal allergies tricor coupons online. Flonase good for allergies flonase dosage for post nasal drip donde comprar xenical orlistat mexico flonase for dust mite allergy orlistat usa price generic name for flonase nasal spray. Orlistat preo e onde comprar orlistat usa can i buy orlistat over the counter in australia free tricor coupons. Amoxicillin buy online usa amoxicillin for sale in usa tricor coupons flonase dosage for infants propecia pills price donde comprar orlistat en mexico. Nasonex or flonase for allergies Generic pharmacy drug list propecia hair growth pills Orlistat 60mg $73.2 - $1.22 Per pill. Orlistat online usa purchase orlistat uk viagra for sale from pfizer xenical orlistat price uk flonase nasal spray for sinus infection flonase nasal spray directions for use. Orlistat over the counter usa is flonase good for cat allergies flonase dosage for sinus infection orlistat cheap uk orlistat 120 mg price uk. Buy orlistat us buy orlistat usa viagra for sale victoria bc buy amoxicillin online usa orlistat 60mg uk is flonase used for allergies can you buy orlistat in the uk. Nasal spray for allergies flonase flonase for allergic cough amoxicillin usa prescription cost for flonase orlistat cost uk viagra for sale canberra. Propecia pills uk viagra for sale canada flonase for headache flonase for sinus pain viagra for sale cape town orlistat 120 mg italia tricor medicine coupons. Viagra for sale birmingham flonase safe for high blood pressure orlistat preo comprar viagra for sale gold coast flonase for cat allergies flonase for pet allergies. Propecia regrowth pills propecia pills over the counter tricor drug coupons amoxicillin price in usa viagra for sale galway. Propecia pills order propecia pills hair loss orlistat otc us flonase instructions for proper use flonase for mold allergies. Propecia pills for sale amoxicillin 500mg price in usa propecia pills amoxicillin in us drug store mascara brands flonase nasal spray for allergies.

  • buy orlistat online ireland
  • orlistat buy online australia
  • orlistat hexal france
  • orlistat sandoz france
  • orlistat to buy in australia
  • orlistat hexal online bestellen schweiz
  • buy orlistat in australia
  • can i buy orlistat over the counter in australia




Viagra pfizer online apotheke orlistat generico in italia que es orlistat generico orlistat generico ultrafarma. Proscar for female hair loss orlistat generico online orlistat generico germed bula proscar 5mg for hair loss generic albuterol rescue inhaler generic albuterol solution. Proscar for hair loss ventolin inhaler doses proscar for prostate cancer depo provera vs oral contraceptives generic albuterol inhaler cost will doctors prescribe proscar for hair loss. Xenical generic orlistat generic 120mg birth control pill vs depo provera orlistat hexal bestellen schweiz orlistat generico resultados. Kamagra tablets australia cuanto cuesta orlistat generico mexico remedio orlistat generico orlistate generico germed bula proscar for hair loss risks. How much proscar to take for hair loss depo provera effectiveness vs pill dosage of proscar for hair loss generic proscar for hair loss. 0.73 generico xenical orlistat 120 mg Orlistat 60mg $73.2 - $1.22 Per pill is proscar used for hair loss ventolin doses per inhaler price for proscar. Cutting proscar for hair loss should i take proscar for hair loss generic albuterol inhalers available depo provera vs birth control pill. Cost for antabuse orlistat generico acquisto viagra originale pfizer online orlistate generico preo precio orlistat generico mexico viagra kaufen pfizer online bestellen. Proscar dose for bph orlistat generico en farmacias similares orlistat generico en mexico Kann man kamagra rezeptfrei kaufen xenical orlistat generico 120mg orlistat online bestellen schweiz. Generic albuterol availability prescription for antabuse viagra online from pfizer viagra pfizer online italia viagra pfizer online australia pfizer viagra for sale online. Antabuse tablets for sale ventolin doses for pediatrics antabuse pills for sale proscar dose for hair loss proscar dosage for hair loss. Viagra online kaufen pfizer pfizer viagra price canada generic albuterol mdi orlistate generico preco what does proscar do for hair loss. Orlistat generico senza ricetta generic proscar for sale orlistat en generico orlistat generico germed preço. Generic albuterol sulfate inhaler provera 5mg vs 10mg proscar dosage for bph orlistat generic drug store cosmetics brands proscar vs avodart for hair loss private prescription for antabuse. What is the clinical classification for the medication proscar generic albuterol sulfate will a doctor prescribe proscar for hair loss. How do i get a prescription for antabuse buy generic xenical orlistat where can i buy generic albuterol inhaler orlistat hexal online bestellen schweiz.

  • orlistat to buy in australia
  • safe online drug stores in canada
  • major drug stores in canada
  • homeopathic drug stores in canada
  • orlistat hexal france
  • drug stores open canada day
  • orlistat sandoz france


< Levitra in der apotheke kaufen :: Propecia where to buy canada >

June 04, 2010

Independence of Party-Appointed Experts Under the Revised IBA Evidence Rules

A revised and updated version of the International Bar Association Rules for the Taking of Evidence in International Arbitration (“Revised Rules”) is moving rapidly toward formal adoption by the IBA. The draft was published for comment several weeks ago and the comment period ended June 1.

 

This is the first of perhaps several commentaries on particular aspects of the Revised Rules. 

 

An important new feature of the Revised Rules concerns the contents of the written reports of party-appointed experts. Under the Revised Rules, the Expert Report must contain “a statement of his or her independence from the Parties, their legal advisers and the Arbitral Tribunal.” Further, if the Expert Report has been translated, it shall contain “a statement as to the language in which it was originally prepared, and the language in which the Party-Appointed Expert anticipates giving testimony at the Evidentiary Hearing.”

 

The phrasing here concerning independence seems carefully calculated to encourage but not require that the party-appointed Expert should actually be “independent” in the same sense that an arbitrator must be. It also appears intended to encourage but not require fairly extensive disclosure by the Expert of his or her prior business or personal relationships with the parties, their counsel, and members of the Arbitral Tribunal.

 

It remains up to the parties and their counsel who select their experts to bear whatever credibility risks might be associated with a conclusory or qualified statement of independence, or with a less than fulsome disclosure of past relationships with the appointing party and its counsel. 

 

The new requirement on translation may help to expose the role of counsel in the preparation of the Expert Report, especially where, as is often the case in investor-State arbitrations, English-speaking investor counsel may have to rely heavily on experts in legal and economic aspects of a State whose official language is not English and whose professional ranks are not generally bi-lingual. 

 

These new aspects of the rule on Expert Reports highlight for arbitrators some options to streamline proceedings. For example, a Tribunal might inform the parties that it elects not to allow Document Requests for documents concerning the Expert’s relationships with the appointing party and its counsel. In conjunction with taking that position, the tribunal might announce that it will place considerable weight on the Expert’s declaration of independence when it comes time to decide whether the conclusions drawn by the Expert are entirely objective. Cross-examination for bias will tend to be more limited if document production on this subject is off limits.

But the Tribunal can make clear to the parties, at the preliminary hearing or terms of reference stage, that with this limitation on effective cross-examination for expert bias comes a corresponding duty of full disclosure, the absence of which may lead to adverse inferences about the Expert’s objectivity.

 

It may be that large law firms will continue to use as experts large economics consulting firms to whom they have turned for help on many prior occasions. Compliance by such firms with the new statement of independence requirement is likely to reveal in many cases that the consulting firm has had prior engagements for opposing counsel as well. Such firms thrive because their opinions are respected for objectivity notwithstanding that they may have worked in the past for the same law firm in its representation of other clients.

 

Thus it remains to be seen whether a new standard of independence for party-appointed experts will emerge, by which the expert is expected to have the same degree of independence as an arbitrator. But the required statements concerning independence and translation, if heeded by the parties and used effectively by the tribunal, can prevent the issue of possible expert bias from becoming a time-consuming sideshow in an already difficult case.

 

It is important here to take note of the path not taken in these relatively modest steps concerning the independence of party-appointed experts. In September 2007, the Chartered Instutute of Arbitrators (“CIArb”) had issued a “Protocol for the Use of Party-Appointed Expert Witnesses in International Arbitration,” prepared by its Practices and Standards Committee.

The CIArb Protocol urged what some might argue to be a laudable but unrealistic model for party-engaged expertise: that the role of the party-appointed expert should be to assist the Tribunal, by objective analysis, rather than to advocate the position of the party that appointed her. In line with that mission, the CIArb Protocol requires that the Expert Report include a Declaration, in the specific language of Article 8 of the Protocol, and most notably:

 

“(a) I understand that my duty in giving evidence in this arbitration is to assist the arbitral tribunal decide the issues in respect of which expert evidence is adduced. I have complied with, and will continue to comply with, that duty.

(b) I confirm that this is my own, impartial, objective, unbiased opinion which has not been influenced by the pressures of the dispute resolution process or by any party to the arbitration.”

 

It merits note that in mandating such a declaration, the CIArb Protocol went further in regulating the expert’s conduct than did the 2005 UK Civil Justice Council’s Protocol for the Instruction of Experts to Give Evidence in Civil Claims (“CJC Protocol”). Article 4 of the CJC Protocol (maintained in the October 2009 updating) declares that experts have a “duty to help the court” that “overrides any obligation to the person instructing or paying them.” And the same Article exhorts experts to “provide opinions which are independent, regardless of the pressures of litigation.” But the CJC Protocol did not propose specific declarations concerning independence as required or even recommended contents of the expert’s written report.

 

Here I cannot resist a “war story” that is instructive. Some 20 years ago, as counsel to a US company in an ICC arbitration against its Italian supplier, there was a serious question whether the choice of law clause called for, in the circumstances, application of Italian law or the law of New York. I submitted expert opinions on each potentially applicable body of law. The New York law expert, a retired judge of the state’s highest court, recived and edited drafts of his opinion that had been prepared by counsel. The Italian law expert, a professor in Milan, refused to even meet with me to discuss the case, on the basis that he did not wish for his objectivity to be impaired by the advocacy I would presumably introduce into our discussions. This message was conveyed on the day I arrived in Milan for our scheduled meeting. Instead, I enjoyed a sunny late winter day on the ski slopes in Courmayeur. The professor’s opinion was a model of clarity and elegance — in its original Italian and in translation — and it significantly advanced my client’s case.

 

One can imagine that lawyers with common law training and experience within the IBA Rules working group expressed concern about the constraints on counsel-expert interaction that could arise from imposing such a declaration requirement on party-appointed experts. The IBA Rule strikes a balance by injecting independence as a laudable objective for party-appointed experts, but without legislating independence criteria that would require advocates from different legal cultures to conform their conduct to a uniform transnational standard.

 

One Response to “Independence of Party-Appointed Experts Under the Revised IBA Evidence Rules”

  1. May I submit that there is one aspect of expertise that needs to be aproached with some care? Firstly, most, if not all commercial arbitration (and adjudication) is about fact. Secondly, where the issues are technical, each party may require expert assistance not only in preparation but also in presentation.

    There is a strong argument for experts whose role is that of adjunct ‘counsel’, presenting technical argument and questioning both witnesses of opinion and of fact. Inevitably, when scientists and technicians do adopt this adjunctive role, they will be constrained by the objectivity inherent in their formation. They will not have the luxury of the legal advocate’s ‘licence’, itself difficlt to define.

    It will be important for technicians to distinguish clearly the role of a witness af any kind, whoever pays, from this role of a technical advisor to the legal team (and possibly technical advocate).

    Whether one and the same person can act in both roles is a matter for debate. I should declare an interest; I have done so. It was ncessary to make it clear what was offered as evidence and what argument. The tribunal was aware when I was performing which duty. Desirable? I an not sure.