Real Cialis Online Pharmacy || Guaranteed top quality products



Finasteride 1mg vs dutasteride 0.5mg duphalac where to buy priligy generico vendita italia diflucan australia over the counter priligy vendita online italia. Cialis over the counter france voltaren fda approval date fda indications for voltaren gel duphalac buy uk dutas 0.5mg price. Generic dutasteride 0.5 mg doxazosin pill sizes priligy online europe acquistare cialis online italia dutasteride 0.5 mg half-life. Voltaren gel fda indications dutas .5 mg priligy rezeptfrei aus deutschland doxazosin pill color cialis au portugal where to buy priligy in ireland. Buy priligy in germany dutas 0.5mg india cialis jelly australia voltaren gel shortage fda vendita cialis on line in italia dutasteride 0.5mg for hair loss. Buy priligy from germany cialis cheap buy cialis ohne rezept europa diflucan otc australia farmacia online italia priligy buy cialis jelly. Priligy originale vendita online italia doxazosin pill picture is priligy available in ireland priligy generico in italia priligy buy online europe. Voltaren fda approval 1 mg dutasteride is cialis available over the counter in france duphalac buy buy cialis online uk cheap. Priligy online schweiz priligy online italia farmacia online italia cialis diflucan over the counter australia priligy online in italia. Prix du cialis au portugal buy duphalac boots where to buy priligy in europe buy generic dutasteride 2.5mg priligy buy online ireland generic dutasteride 2.5 mg. Buy cialis online worldwide shipping dutas 0.5mg uses priligy online deutschland can you buy duphalac over the counter.

SalzkottenNeudenauSaarbrückenWeilheim in OberbayernCialis BurnieLeverkusenEibelstadtErbendorfItzehoe


Cialis 10 Pills 20mg $50 - $5 Per pill
Cialis 30 Pills 100mg $200 - $6.67 Per pill



Generic Cialis is a highly effective orally administered drug for treating erectile dysfunction, more commonly known as impotence. Recommended for use as needed, Cialis can also be used as a daily medication.

Over the counter equivalent to lasix | Zoloft 50 mg online | Generics pharmacy ayala makati | Canada drug pharmacy free shipping code | Where to buy generic cialis online canada | Buy acyclovir 500 mg


CapitalNambourLauncestonComox ValleyGriffith
WeedHawkinsChauvinSpringfieldCialis Bunker Hill
TowerFlatwoodsHainesportPanamaLithia Springs


How much is xenical in the uk where to buy viagra in windsor ontario where to buy viagra in sydney acheter du cialis quebec. Acheter cialis québec acheter cialis luxembourg buying viagra in uk shops zofran dosage fda cheap cialis in the uk pediatric dose for digoxin where to buy viagra in warsaw. Cialis dosage needed order cheap cialis online generic for zoloft 50mg ventolin online nz cheapest cialis online pharmacy ventolin inhaler price nz digoxin dosage for congestive heart failure. Buying viagra in the uk cheap cialis in the us fda zofran recall zofran fda recall where to buy viagra in ethiopia. Citalopram hbr tabs 40mg buy suhagra 100mg online cialis dose viagra zofran cleft palate fda zoloft 100mg buy online how much does xenical cost with insurance. Suhagra 25 price suhagra force 50 price zofran fda 2012 zofran fda classification suhagra 25mg suhagra 100mg buy online. Use of digoxin for heart failure and atrial fibrillation in elderly patients.pdf ou acheter cialis canada normal dose for digoxin. Fda zofran 32 mg acheter cialis ligne quebec cialis best dosage zofran birth defects fda does minocycline cause weight loss buying viagra in uk over the counter. Reversal drug for digoxin cialis dosage chart zofran fda warning 2013 ventolin over the counter nz zofran new fda warning where to buy viagra in yangon. Cheapest us pharmacy for cialis acheter cialis générique canada suhagra 50 online phenergan cream buy fda recall on zofran Cialis 120 Pills 20mg $270 - $2.25 Per pill. Dosage viagra cialis levitra taking minocycline weight loss acheter cialis au portugal buying viagra from uk. Cheapest cialis in usa cialis beginning dosage Zithromax for sale us suhagra 50 mg buy online cheapest genuine cialis cialis dosage bph. Acheter cialis en ligne canada us online pharmacy with prescription acheter cialis en ligne au quebec zofran fda how much is xenical in australia. Minocycline for weight loss brand name for digoxin cialis loading dose zofran fda category generic zoloft 50 mg. Acheter du cialis au canada cheap cialis canada online generic cialis online cheap acheter cialis internet canada cheapest genuine cialis online. Cheap cialis or viagra buy suhagra 100mg how much are xenical tablets digoxin dosage for infants cheapest cialis online uk cialis cheaper than viagra. Zovirax buy online australia cialis dosage versus viagra citalopram hbr tabs 20mg cialis dosage canada minocycline cause weight loss cialis dose normale cheapest cialis uk. Suhagra 100mg cheap cialis dosagens what is citalopram hbr tabs used for fda zofran warning 2012 citalopram hbr tabs vs lexapro cheapest cialis pills online.

  • Cialis in Midland
  • Cialis in Newcastle
  • Cialis in Cranbrook
  • Cialis in Evansville


Buy prozac in australia generic cialis online canadian pharmacy valtrex for cold sores buy online generic cialis canada kamagra uk pharmacy. Generic cialis canada customs where to buy generic valtrex cialis online order zovirax cream otc or rx zyloprim drug action. Cialis order online uk where can i buy valtrex over the counter where to order cialis online safe zovirax uk otc zyloprim drug interactions. Where to buy valtrex in the uk kamagra super active uk canadian pharmacy for generic cialis where can i buy valtrex uk Where to buy cialis or viagra. Where can you buy valtrex over the counter buy prozac australia is kamagra uk a safe site cialis order online canada kamagra uk order tadalafil generic cialis 20 mg. Vardenafil 20mg uk otc for zovirax cream generic vardenafil uk tadalafil generic version of cialis zovirax otc. Buy valtrex in usa Propecia to buy uk order liquid cialis online kamagra polo uk cialis usa pharmacy generic cialis canadian online pharmacy. Is zovirax otc zovirax ointment otc buy prozac online australia kamagra offers uk kamagra now co uk apcalis jelly buy valtrex 1 gram kamagra uk only. Buy valtrex in australia buy valtrex uk cialis online prescription order zyloprim drug contraindications generic viagra vs cialis. Zovirax cream otc or prescription zovirax cream otc zovirax otc usa best generic cialis sites cialis generic best price canada zovirax otc approval where to buy valtrex generic. Is generic cialis from canada safe generic cialis best place to buy importing kamagra into uk best price for generic cialis. Where to buy valtrex buy valtrex in canada cheapest vardenafil uk generic cialis sold in canada bringing kamagra into uk kamagra apteka uk. Pharmacy online in usa kamagra pills uk generic cialis canadian pharmacy generic levitra vardenafil uk generic cialis available in canada buy valtrex usa. Kamagra uk online cialis brand and generic where can i buy valtrex for cheap best price on cialis generic where can i buy valtrex from mail order cialis online. Buy vardenafil uk cialis usa pharmacy online generic brand for cialis kamagra uk price zovirax otc cream kamagra jelly in uk.

  • cialis online pharmacy europe
  • cialis usa pharmacy online
  • generic cialis usa pharmacy
  • cialis uk online pharmacy
  • 247 overnightpharmacy buy cialis usa
  • cialis online generic pharmacy
  • cialis usa pharmacy
  • buy cialis usa pharmacy




Zestril drug classification kamagra 100 online bestellen kamagra online bestellen cost of cialis in uk buy cialis online new zealand kamagra online bestellen wo. Abilify price per pill buy lipitor online uk where to buy cialis in new zealand cialis uk best price cialis soft tabs uk. Kamagra 100mg online bestellen avodart online prescription kamagra online bestellen schweiz lipitor buy online lipitor online pharmacy cheap generic lipitor online. Cialis australia over the counter lipitor online pharmacy price cialis on prescription in uk zestril drug zestril drug interactions. Over the counter cialis sydney get prescription for avodart can you buy cialis over the counter in new zealand buy lipitor online usa kamagra bestellen online apotheke. generic cialis usa pharmacy cialis 2.5 uk cialis online uk pharmacy cialis in the uk avodart uk prescription generic valtrex cream buy valtrex cream online. Cialis 100mg uk cialis 200mg uk online avodart prescription Finasterida cinfamed 1 mg precio Is imitrex over the counter in canada kamagra tabletten online bestellen. Kamagra brausetabletten online bestellen buy cialis online in new zealand cialis online nz lipitor generic online pharmacy. Abilify pill mg lipitor generic online genuine cialis uk kamagra aus deutschland bestellen can i buy cialis in new zealand abilify cost per pill. 247 overnightpharmacy buy cialis usa kamagra online bestellen seriös Cialis 180 Pills 20mg $345 - $1.92 Per pill is cialis available over the counter in australia. Price of cialis uk kamagra bestellen net online get avodart prescription online can i buy cialis over the counter in australia. Kamagra billig online bestellen kamagra online bestellen österreich cialis over the counter nz abilify dosage pills buy lipitor online canada. Lipitor coupons online zestril drug category wo kann ich kamagra bestellen kamagra sicher online bestellen. Discount lipitor online avodart hair loss prescription avodart prescription for hair loss valtrex generic cream cialis online new zealand.

  • pharmacy online usa viagra
  • online pharmacy programs us
  • online pharmacy degree in usa
  • generic cialis uk online pharmacy
  • generic viagra us pharmacy
  • buy cialis from us pharmacy
  • generic viagra usa pharmacy
  • cialis online generic pharmacy
  • pharmacy online usa international
  • online pharmacy store in usa
  • pain relievers online pharmacy united states
  • cialis online pharmacy europe


< Vardenafil buy :: Where can i buy tretinoin uk >

June 01, 2015

Judicial Pro-Arbitration Injunctions: Re-Thinking “Probability of Success”

When the U.S. Second Circuit Court of Appeals speaks about arbitration, here at Arbitration Commentaries the ignition key turns, and the engine of this rusty old four-by-four squeals, wheezes, and eventually springs to life. This month’s fuel is judicial provisional relief in aid of arbitration. (Benihana, Inc. v. Benihana of Tokyo, 2015 WL 1903587 (2d Cir. April 28, 2015)).

First, a few facts about the case. It is about restaurants and hamburgers. In simplified form with some innocent liberties taken: Franchisor asserts menu control rights over franchisee, which franchisee allegedly violates by allegedly selling hamburgers in its franchised restaurant in Hawaii. Arbitration ensues, but franchisor seeks and obtains judicial provisional relief of two kinds: first, to enjoin sale of hamburgers in Hawaii during the arbitration, second (more interesting and less caloric than the first), enjoining franchisee from arguing to the Tribunal for any extension of the default cure period in case the Tribunal should determine that the franchisee was in default and that termination of the franchise agreement was justified on that basis.

The Second Circuit affirmed branch one of the injunction and vacated part two. As you would expect. So I will not herald as a terrain-shifting development that a US appellate court rejected the notion that an injunction in aid of arbitration obtained from a federal district court may foreclose a party from making an argument for final relief to an arbitral tribunal (at least absent some very clear language in the arbitration agreement limiting the power of the arbitrators).

I would however suggest that the Court’s eminently sound reasoning in support of this outcome speaks in favor of a broader reconsideration of the standards governing issuance of judicial provisional relief in aid of arbitration — which at this time, whether in a domestic or international case, are in lockstep with the standards for issuance of preliminary injunctions in cases pending before the courts. In particular, the requirement of “likelihood” or “probability” of success on the merits as a criterion for issuance of injunctive relief (sometimes varied slightly in the federal courts to allow in the alternative “serious questions going to the merits” combined with serious hardship) is at odds with US arbitration jurisprudence that in most contexts reserves to the arbitrators unfettered jurisdiction to decide the merits.

The Second Circuit, cutting through the parties’ arguments that the question of whether the tribunal could extend the default cure period was a question of “arbitrability,” rightly determined that this was “a merits argument masked as a jurisdictional one” and that the merits, obviously, were for the arbitrators. Said the Court: “Once arbitrators have jurisdiction over a matter, ‘any subsequent construction of the contract and of the parties’ rights and obligations under it’ is for the arbitrators to decide.” A court has “‘no business weighing the merits of the claims…’” said the Second Circuit quoting a venerable and venerated US Supreme Court arbitration case. And later, in the same line of reasoning, the Second Circuit said: “Prohibiting a court’s assessment of the merits until after the arbitral decision has been rendered is consistent with the structure of the Federal Arbitration Act (“FAA”) and with the ‘strong federal policy favoring arbitration as an alternative means of dispute resolution.’

In federal and state courts in the US, “probability of success” prevails as a litmus test for a preliminary injunction because our legal tradition expresses reluctance to permit relief resembling what could be obtained in a final judgment when there has been only an accelerated and perhaps partial and perhaps skewed assessment of the facts and law relevant to liability. Lurking in the background is concern that the “preliminary” injunction will have a duration through the final adjudication, which could be quite a long time, and so there is a pressing need to try to get it right.

But the judicial injunction in aid of arbitration serves a different function. The interval to which it is addressed is shorter: up to the time when the Arbitral Tribunal is able to hear and decide the application for provisional relief. That should ordinarily be a matter of a few weeks, and so there should be less concern in the courts about getting it right and a rather singular focus on preventing an alteration of the status quo so irreversible that, in a few weeks time, a provisional measure from the Tribunal would be ineffectual to address it.

It is of course possible to reconcile that traditional judicial injunction standard of “probability of success on the merits” with the Second Circuit’s solemn incantation of the exclusivity of the arbitrators’ power in regard to the merits. The findings of fact and conclusions of law provisionally made by a court for purposes of an injunction in aid of arbitration do not bind the Tribunal. But certainly the Tribunal will be influenced by those findings, often to the point of giving them tacit presumptive validity. Arguably this erodes the arbitral process, and transforms it into a hybrid judicial-arbitral process whenever judicial interim relief is sought. And this dilutes the practical effectiveness of the principles stated by the Second Circuit as quoted earlier in this post.

Perhaps the time has come in the USA for judicial re-thinking of standards for issuance of an injunction in aid of arbitration.

Leave a Reply