Cipro dosage with or without food topamax generic vs brand name cipro with food or without plavix or coumadin for atrial fibrillation plavix or aspirin which is better. Lisinopril brand vs generic
hydrochlorothiazide purchase online take cipro with food or not ciprofloxacin with food or not cipro or bactrim for kidney infection. Hydrochlorothiazide 25mg $35.11 - $0.59 Per pill
is hydrochlorot and hydrochlorothiazide the same medication. Accutane for sale cheap cipro with food or empty stomach plavix or aspirin cipro with food or not blood pressure medication hydrochlorothiazide accutane online cheap. What is the medication hydrochlorothiazide used for hydrochlorothiazide over the counter equivalent cheapest generic accutane accutane buy cheap. Ciprofloxacin with food or without buy acyclovir 800 mg cheap accutane for cheap where to get accutane cheap. Over the counter hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg topamax brand price buy acyclovir online cheap cheap accutane for sale ciprofloxacin iv or oral. Accutane buy online cheap hydrochlorothiazide medication cheapest accutane online what is hydrochlorothiazide medication for. Get accutane cheap plavix or aspirin for stroke prevention buy cheap acyclovir uk blood pressure medication hydrochlorothiazide dosage cipro with food or on empty stomach. hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg buy
water pill hydrochlorothiazide over the counter hydrochlorothiazide high blood pressure medication. Order hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg online cheap accutane for sale online canada pharmacys online apo hydrochlorothiazide medication accutane cheap online. Generic accutane cheap hydrochlorothiazide over the counter buy cheap acyclovir online how much does generic flagyl cost where to get cheap accutane medication hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg. Where can i buy clomid in england
ciprofloxacin dosage before or after meals high blood pressure medication hydrochlorothiazide. Where to buy cheap accutane buy brand name topamax online where can i get accutane cheap accutane cheapest accutane cheapest price topamax generic brands.
|Hydrochlorothiazide Chilliwack||Wyong||Carnarvon||Toowoomba||Hydrochlorothiazide Port Augusta||Port Hedland||Murray Bridge||Greater Vancouver||Cessnock|
Hydrochlorothiazide 25mg $47.4 - $0.53 Per pill
Hydrochlorothiazide is used for treating high blood pressure.
|Scotts Valley||Philadelphia||Jackson Center||Au Sable Forks||Neptune|
Buy xenical 120mg hard capsules orlistat cost of zoloft 25 mg levitra 20 mg buy online hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg tab cost. Generic tretinoin 0.05 weight loss on hydrochlorothiazide entocort generic entocort generic name hydrochlorothiazide online pharmacy. Toradol nome generico
buy cheap levitra online lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide online levitra for sale online. Is tretinoin generic for retin a how much does zoloft 50 mg cost zoloft price in canada lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide and weight loss. Hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg online generic tretinoin cream 0.05 online pharmacy canada free shipping coreg 25 mg tablet purchase levitra online. Lasix online bestellen ohne rezept
does hydrochlorothiazide help with weight loss hydrochlorothiazide for weight loss. Can coreg tablets be crushed how much does generic zoloft cost lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide weight loss hydrochlorothiazide weight loss reviews. Orlistate 84 capsulas preзo corega tablete non generic levitra online generic topical tretinoin can hydrochlorothiazide help with weight loss. Tretinoin cream 1 generic orlistat capsules 60mg retin a vs generic tretinoin coreg tablet picture how much does the generic zoloft cost. Purchase hydrochlorothiazide online zoloft brand price hydrochlorothiazide buy online coreg tablets 6.25 mg coreg tablet Where can i buy xenical in sydney
hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg cost. Hydrochlorothiazide online canada zoloft price us orlistat 84 capsulas preзo orlistat capsules 120 mg cheap levitra online uk generic tretinoin 0.1. Orlistat 60mg 84 capsules sandoz orlistat 120 mg 42 capsulas zoloft cost uk zoloft 50 mg cost.
- Hydrochlorothiazide in Tallahassee
- Hydrochlorothiazide in Clarksville
- Hydrochlorothiazide in Escondido
- Hydrochlorothiazide in Ore.
Buy retin a uk online generic substitute for vytorin amoxicillin 500mg buy online buy amoxicillin online uk next day delivery retin a micro buy online uk. Retin-a micro gel buy online Can you buy viagra online canada
generic vytorin 10 20 mg hydrochlorothiazide cost without insurance hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 cost vytorin 10/10 generico. Hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg street price buy amoxicillin online from canada diclofenac patch otc is diclofenac an otc drug nombre generico de vytorin 10/20. Where buy viagra australia amoxicillin 500 mg online pharmacy retin a gel buy online uk benazepril hydrochlorothiazide cost. Eurax lotion buy can you buy viagra in melbourne generic telmisartan hydrochlorothiazide amoxicillin antibiotics online uk Hydrochlorothiazide 25mg $47.4 - $0.53 Per pill. Diclofenac otc usa hydrochlorothiazide generic for vytorin 10/20 generic losartan potassium and hydrochlorothiazide tablets price buy viagra western australia. Retin a micro buy online vytorin 10 10 generic diclofenac gel otc retin-a micro gel online pharmacy where to buy retin a online uk. Retin a online pharmacy uk generic hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg tab price price of hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg. Hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg tab price amoxicillin online apotheke where can i buy retin a online uk diclofenac sodium otc uk price of lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide. Hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg cost prescription retin a online where can i buy viagra in nsw amoxicillin online order for humans buy retin a 0.1 online uk. Buy amoxicillin online in uk generic version of hydrochlorothiazide hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg tab cost price for hydrochlorothiazide.
Buy avodart canada Clomid bestellen erfahrung Buy viagra in western australia Buy accutane online united states Is xenical available over the counter in australia Buy propecia canada pharmacy Flagyl buy online
- buy hydrochlorothiazide 50 mg
- purchase hydrochlorothiazide online
- buy hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg
- lisinopril and hydrochlorothiazide tablets 20 mg 12.5mg
- hydrochlorothiazide for sale online
- hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg buy online
- lisinopril and hydrochlorothiazide tablets usp 10 mg 12.5mg
- lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide buy online
Generic proscar vs propecia kamagra oral jelly sachets uk augmentin generika mepha hydrochlorothiazide brand name. Cialis 5mg tablet propecia vs finasteride 5 mg brand name for lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide generika augmentin kamagra oral jelly online pharmacy augmentin generika mepha. Cost of propecia vs proscar hydrochlorothiazide brand names australia kamagra oral jelly online apotheke cialis tablets for sale uk. Buying viagra online uk
losartan potassium and hydrochlorothiazide brands in india cialis 5 mg 30 tablet cost propecia vs finasteride generic. Hydrochlorothiazide tablets brand name generic finasteride 1mg vs propecia hydrochlorothiazide brand name or generic hydrochlorothiazide brand name philippines. Kamagra oral jelly birmingham uk brand name valsartan hydrochlorothiazide hydrochlorothiazide brand australia metoprolol hydrochlorothiazide combination brand name. Metoprolol hydrochlorothiazide brand name kamagra oral jelly uk sales amiloride hydrochlorothiazide brand name. Enalapril hydrochlorothiazide brand name online pharmacy degree us cialis 20mg tablets 4 augmentin 625 generika buy motilium online usa. Finasteride vs propecia hair loss propecia 5mg vs 1mg cialis tablets 20mg hydrochlorothiazide-lisinopril brand name kamagra oral jelly 100mg uk hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg oral tablet. Cialis 20 mg 30 tablet buy motilium instants online cialis tablets 20mg price triamterene hydrochlorothiazide brand name finasteride vs propecia price. Telmisartan hydrochlorothiazide brand name tadapox online kaufen cheap kamagra oral jelly australia propecia oral vs topical propecia vs finasteride 5mg. Hydrochlorothiazide tablets or capsules hydrochlorothiazide brand name in egypt cialis 5mg 28 tablet hydrochlorothiazide weight loss or gain cialis 20mg tablets uk. Kamagra oral jelly uk shop cialis 50 mg tablets triamterene hydrochlorothiazide brand names hydrochlorothiazide brand names in india. Bisoprolol hydrochlorothiazide brand name order motilium online uk cialis tablets 20mg uk propecia vs proscar hair loss. What is the brand name for hydrochlorothiazide cialis tablets 20mg australia cialis 50 mg 30 tablet hydrochlorothiazide generic and brand names. Losartan potassium hydrochlorothiazide brands brand name for hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg cialis tablet 5mg buy motilium online ireland hydrochlorothiazide brand name in india. Propecia 0.5 mg vs 1mg finasteride generico vs propecia generic finasteride vs propecia motilium to buy online brand name of hydrochlorothiazide. Cialis tablets uk cheap kamagra oral jelly uk kamagra oral jelly uk fast delivery kamagra oral jelly uk next day motilium buy online uk. Hydrochlorothiazide brand name canada olmesartan hydrochlorothiazide brand name generic finasteride vs propecia 2013 rogaine vs propecia cost. Brand names of telmisartan hydrochlorothiazide cialis tablets 10mg cialis 20 mg tablets uk finasteride 5 mg vs propecia.
< Clopidogrel tablet dose :: Precio viagra generico en españa >
January 30, 2009
- lisinopril and hydrochlorothiazide tablets 20 mg 12.5mg
- pharmacy online us
- canada pharmacy online viagra
- buy hydrochlorothiazide online
- online pharmacy tech schools in texas
- canada online pharmacy domperidone
- online pharmacy degree texas
- pharmacy online schools in texas
Removal of New York Convention Case from State to Federal Court
I report today on an unusual case, involving a rarely-encountered issue. The case, decided by a U.S. District Judge in New York in the last days of 2008, is Vistra Trust Co. v. Stoffel, 2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 106493 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 29, 2008). The issue: the right of a litigant to transfer a case filed in state court to a federal court (in federal practice parlance, âremovalâ) when the case involves an arbitration agreement or award governed by the U.N. Convention on Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (âNew York Conventionâ).
In Vistra, a family trust brought fraud claims against its former trustee, and two entities related to the trustee, in the New York State Supreme Court. The trustee, claiming the disputes were arbitrable, and that arbitrations involving the same issues were pending in Switzerland, sought to remove the case to the U.S. District Court under Chapter Two of the Federal Arbitration Act (âFAAâ), which implements the New York Convention. Presumably the trusteeâs intention was to move before the U.S. court to compel arbitration, and for dismissal or a stay of the action pending arbitration. But the result in the case is that the removal was held to be improper, because the consent of the related entities to the removal was not obtained by the defendant trustee. And so the case has been sent back (âremandedâ) to the New York State court.
Some background is in order: Chapter 1 of the FAA, governing domestic arbitrations, does not confer jurisdiction on U.S. federal courts. Federal jurisdiction in a domestic case to enforce an arbitration agreement or award is based on two requirements. First, the matter must involve interstate or foreign commerce (a requirement usually met given federal law giving broad interpretation to such âcommerceâ ). Second, the case must meet traditional requirements for federal jurisdiction: either a question of United States law (other than a question under the FAA) or diversity of citizenship. Chapter 2 of the FAA has a jurisdiction-conferring provision that Chapter 1 lacks: It provides that a case âfalls under the [New York] Conventionâ when it involves international commerce, and further states that a case that âfalls under the Convention. . . arises under the laws and treaties of the United States.â That is to say, such a case qualifies for federal jurisdiction based on a question of federal law, even if the only question presented is the application of the Convention or Chapter Two of the FAA.
Section 205 of the FAA governs removal of New York Convention cases from state to federal court. It provides that such a case, i.e. one âthat relates to an arbitration agreement or award falling under the Conventionâ may be removed to the federal court by âthe defendant or the defendants.â That section goes on to state that â[t]he procedure for removal of causes otherwise provided by law shall apply.â
Case law interpreting the same phrase âthe defendant or the defendantsâ found in the general removal statute, has held that the statute requires that multiple defendants give unanimous consent to the removal, absent some narrow exceptions (e.g. separate and independent claims, or defendants named as parties in the pleading but never served with process).
In Vistra, the Defendants argued that the same words in the arbitration statute should not be construed to require unanimity â for the reason that it was inferable, from the very existence of a special removal statute for New York Convention cases, that Congress sought to channel Convention cases into the federal courts to encourage uniformity of application. But the Court found no concrete evidence of such Congressional intent. And indeed, the Court noted that in the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, cases brought in the state court are specifically made removable by the foreign state, even if other non-state defendants are involved, whereas no such right of any foreign private entity or person was established when the New York Convention was implemented by Chapter Two of the FAA.
The result of the remand to State Court is that the same motion to compel arbitration and to stay or dismiss the action will, presumably, be made in that forum. The New York State court is bound to apply the Convention and Chapter Two of the FAA.
That outcome is not necessarily unsatisfactory, from the standpoint of consistent enforcement of the Convention. In New York, at least, where a special part of the State Supreme Court is devoted to complex commercial cases, and cases involving international commerce are by no means infrequent, the judges may be expected to have considerable familiarity with the FAA and the Convention. A source of concern to practitioners, however, and one of the reasons removal to federal court of cases initiated in the State court involving the Convention is frequently sought, is that New York, like other states, has its own arbitration statute. It is generally speaking a pro-arbitration statute that does not impose requirements for enforcement of an arbitration agreement that are materially different from federal law. Pre-emption of state arbitration law by the FAA is not categorical, and the general principle is that where state law does not impose more stringent requirements for enforcement of an agreement or award than does federal law, the state and federal statutes shall co-exist and both sha be applied. But in the details of state law concerning enforcement of arbitration agreements â on issues not specifically addressed by statute such as rights and obligations of non-signatories, the scope of arbitrable issues, etc., there may be important deviations from judge-made federal law that has evolved in cases involving the FAA generally and the New York Convention in particular. Thus in the state courts some practitioners will be tempted to seek advantage of requirements under state law, and to argue against pre-emption. This tends to add unnecessary issues, complexity, confusion, and cost.
Despite these concerns, there appears to be no organized initiative in the U.S. arbitration community to promote legislative change that would exclude state court jurisdiction in New York Convention cases. However, cases like Vistra in which the consent of all defendants cannot be obtained should be relatively rare, and in most instances a foreign defendant served in a state court action that should be arbitrated will be able to remove the case and have the arbitrability determination made by a U.S. District Court Judge.