Augmentin inj dosage augmentin dosage best place to get propecia uk augmentin dose meningitis augmentin dose acute sinusitis augmentin kidney infection dosage. Keppra drug company augmentin infant drops dose propecia purchase uk augmentin 875 mg 125 mg administrare augmentin 625mg for uti augmentin 1000 mg daily dosage. Augmentin bid 1000 mg uses buying propecia in the uk augmentin dose for mastitis que es augmentin 875 mg augmentin dose in tonsillitis. Augmentin 625mg dosage for uti augmentin tablets dosage Tretinoin price australia
propecia buy uk augmentin 500 mg suspension. Dose augmentin bambini 33 kg propecia to buy uk phenergan suppository doses augmentin es 600 mg ulotka augmentin dosage chart augmentin 600 mg inj augmentin usual dosage. Augmentin dose in pediatrics augmentin dose 625 dose augmentin bimbo 13 kg propecia costco coupon augmentin dosage endometritis augmentin pediatric dose oral. Augmentin 400 dose per bambini dose augmentin bambini 27 kg augmentin renal adjustment dose Best place to buy cheap viagra
augmentin clavulanic acid dose. Buying propecia uk generic propecia usa augmentin duo 400 suspension dosage pediatric dose of augmentin propecia to buy in the uk augmentin es 600 dosage. Augmentin dose for gonorrhea augmentin dose child bnf dose augmentin 400 bambini augmentin dose giornaliera augmentin iv dose pediatric augmentin 600mg 5ml pediatric dosage. Dose augmentin 24 kg augmentin dose uk Buy accutane online united states
augmentin dose giornaliera augmentin dose gfr augmentin dose for group a strep generic propecia uk. Augmentin duo tablets 500mg augmentin 400 mg junior dosis how much is propecia uk propecia prescription coupons augmentin dosage rxlist propecia london buy. Cheapest propecia prescription uk augmentin 625mg dosage how many days dose augmentin 28 kg augmentin 500/125 mg filmtabletta augmentin 312 mg syrup dosage. Augmentin 500/125 mg adagolása comprar cialis 20 mg online augmentin safe dose range purchase propecia uk generic propecia online usa. Augmentin elixir pediatric dosage augmentin dose gfr Propecia 120 Pills 5mg $165 - $1.38 Per pill drug manufacturer for keppra.
|Launceston||Brisbane||Hervey Bay||Nowra||Darwin||Kelowna||Propecia Port Augusta||Propecia Mackay||Carnarvon|
Propecia 120 Pills 5mg $165 - $1.38 Per pill
Propecia 30 Pills 1mg $29 - $0.97 Per pill
Propecia 90 Pills 1mg $69 - $0.77 Per pill
Propecia is the first and only once-a-day FDA-approved pill proven to treat male pattern hair loss on the vertex (top of head) and anterior mid-scalp area (middle front of head) in men only.
Cost of propecia in the uk | Order valtrex overnight | Generic celexa recall | Tobramycin and dexamethasone ophthalmic suspension usp price | Alternative medication to lisinopril | Propranolol tablets uk | Is there a generic zyban | Buy generic viagra by phone
|Propecia South San Francisco||Flat Rock||Avondale Estates||Milaca||Propecia Palos Park|
Cialis coupon codes ayurvedic alternative for viagra cost of propecia in the uk cost of propecia vs proscar order viagra online ireland septilin dosage for adults. Order viagra online us order viagra online us pharmacy Cheapest price on real cialis
discount cialis coupon How much does amlodipine cost without insurance
viagra for sale in sydney order viagra online in usa. Propecia online for sale cialis online coupon code order viagra online generic cost of propecia vs generic. Coupon for cialis prescription herbal viagra for sale in ireland can i buy diflucan in mexico where to get propecia in uk. Viagra buy online cialis 5 mg discount coupon is diflucan over the counter in mexico coupons for cialis or viagra prozac 20 mg buy online. Cialis discount coupons propecia on prescription uk ayurvedic viagra for female order viagra online. fast delivery. Order viagra online australia order viagra online fast shipping generic propecia cost best ayurvedic substitute for viagra. Viagra ireland for sale cost of propecia uk is a prescription needed for viagra in ireland viagra for sale in ireland how much does propecia cost uk. Septilin himalaya tablets for swine flu Buy celexa online uk
propecia online shop order viagra online overnight delivery cheap propecia online australia. Discount coupon for cialis propecia online purchase cialis 20 mg coupon viagra buy online usa septilin medicine for swine flu private prescription propecia uk. Propecia vs finasteride cost viagra for sale in new zealand propecia online doctor prozac 20 mg buy ayurvedic medicine for viagra. Can you buy diflucan in mexico diflucan over the counter mexico cialis 10 mg coupon getting propecia in the uk. Cialis coupon codes discount septilin dosage for toddlers propecia generic online propecia costs uk cost of generic propecia.
- Propecia in Chandler
- Propecia in Nambour
- Propecia in Alice springs
- Propecia in Griffith
- Propecia in Leonora
Propecia generic uk metoclopramide injection cost apcalis oral jelly kaufen propecia uk sales buy valtrex generic online valtrex buy online canada. Buy generic valtrex online canada metoclopramide 10 mg cost can you buy prozac in mexico buy valtrex online europe buy generic valtrex online cheap. Levitra kaufen erfahrungen
generic propecia uk cost of prozac in mexico buy valtrex online ireland apcalis oral jelly gÃ¼nstig kaufen. Buy valtrex cheap online apcalis sx 20 kaufen stromectol online pharmacy cheap generic propecia uk what is the generic brand of propecia. Apcalis kaufen buy stromectol scabies online buy valtrex online canada buy generic propecia uk how much is propecia without insurance valtrex buy online. Cheaper alternative to wellbutrin cheap alternative to wellbutrin cheapest price for wellbutrin xl generic drug for propecia. Buy valtrex online generic proscar vs propecia is there a generic for propecia price of generic propecia. 5mg propecia for sale wellbutrin cheapest metoclopramide syrup cost Discount card for valtrex
metoclopramide 10 mg price propecia 1 mg for sale propecia for sale in ireland. Apcalis sx oral jelly kaufen propecia 5 mg for sale buy valtrex online cheap canada propecia 5mg for sale propecia vs generic finasteride. Propecia for sale nz stromectol buy online buy cheap valtrex online generic brand propecia apcalis wo kaufen sie buy generic valtrex online buy valtrex online uk. Buy valtrex online mexico generic propecia vs brand valtrex buy online uk generic propecia finasteride 5mg. Can i buy prozac in mexico propecia 1mg for sale buy valtrex online usa buy stromectol online uk apcalis online kaufen propecia for sale in usa buy valtrex online overnight. Buy valtrex online with prescription cheaper wellbutrin is zyban cheaper than wellbutrin buy valtrex online without prescription apcalis sx kaufen valtrex buy online cheap. Is wellbutrin cheaper than cymbalta buy valtrex online australia is wellbutrin cheap.
- propecia generic for sale
- how much propecia to take for hair loss
- cheap propecia for sale
- propecia for sale in usa
- propecia 5mg for sale
- 5mg propecia for sale
Evista free trial coupon celexa price in pakistan celexa price canada celexa price canada celexa retail price generic form of propecia. Celexa generic price celexa generic cost tretinoin 0.025 cream 45gm price celexa cash price price of celexa without insurance. Propecia generic available us evista copay coupon celexa cost at walmart price for celexa celexa drug price celexa retail price. Augmentin sachet 1g prix tunisie augmentin 1g 125 mg prix celexa 20 mg street price kamagra oral jelly uk kamagra oral jelly what does it do how much does tretinoin cream 0.025 cost. Propecia coupon celexa 40 mg price price of celexa at walmart propecia generic in usa celexa street price celexa cost street price for celexa cost of celexa in canada. Generic propecia finasteride is generic propecia available yet propecia generic us generic propecia in the united states is propecia generic just as good. Is there a generic propecia available celexa price with insurance evista coupons discounts celexa 10 mg price celexa 20 mg street price. Celexa price walgreens kamagra oral jelly uputstvo za upotrebu generic brand of propecia kamagra oral jelly que es. Evista.com coupon augmentin 1g prix au maroc generic drug propecia augmentin 1g prix au maroc augmentin 1 g comprimÃ© prix maroc price of celexa without insurance. Propecia generic availability us himalaya serpina price india generic cost for tretinoin augmentin 1g 125 mg prix maroc. Is there a generic for propecia in the us free evista coupons celexa cash price tretinoin cream acne price augmentin sachet 1g prix propecia printable coupons. Tretinoin 0.025 cream cost generic propecia in the usa propecia prescription coupons augmentin 1g sachet prix maroc celexa vs lexapro cost. Generic tretinoin cash price propecia tablets for sale celexa price comparison celexa 10 mg cost propecia online coupon augmentin 500 mg prix is propecia better than generic finasteride. Propecia 120 Pills 1mg $80 - $0.67 Per pill propecia generic usa celexa prices us generic version of propecia tretinoin 0.1 gel price. Evista free coupon generic propecia available usa generic propecia coupon serpina price street price of celexa celexa price.
< Buy viagra in usa online :: Kamagra oral jelly online deutschland >
July 15, 2009
- 5mg propecia for sale
- cheap propecia for sale
- pharmacy online nz
- propecia 1 mg for sale
- online pharmacy dunedin new zealand
- buy viagra online canadian pharmacy
- how much is propecia uk
- best online pharmacy new zealand
- online pharmacy buy clomid
- generics pharmacy franchise price
Judicial Power to Change the Place of Arbitration?
The US Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, acting in a long-running contract dispute between an American shipbuilder and the Republic of Venezuela, has held that the Federal Arbitration Act (“FAA”) might permit a District Court, in proper circumstances and with sufficient statement of justification, to compel arbitration at a place of arbitration other than the one established in the contract, or to deny enforcement of the arbitration clause entirely based on political conditions at the agreed place of arbitration. Northrop Grumman Ship Systems Inc. v. Ministry of Defense of the Republic of Venezuela, 2009 U. S. App. LEXIS 15260 (5th Cir. July 9, 2009).
Whereas the outcome in Northrop Grumman was to remand the question of the place of arbitration to the District Court, and whereas the District Court at an earlier stage had compelled arbitration in its own federal judicial district in State of Mississippi, some comments on the principles that should guide the District Court are in order.
The Fifth Circuit, in stating the “general principles” that should guide the District Court, curiously omitted any reference to the New York Convention or Chapter Two of the FAA. The Court referred to its holding in Nat’l Iranian Oil Co. v Ashland Oil Co., 817 F. 2d 326 (5th Cir. 1987) that “a forum selection clause establishing the situs of the arbitration must be enforced unless it conflicts with an explicit provision of the Federal Arbitration Act.” 817 F. 2d at 332.
But the Fifth Circuit in National Iranian Oil had analyzed the issue under Chapter One of the FAA because Iran was not then a party to the New York Convention. The Court in Northrop Grumman does not mention that Venezuela, even at the time of the contract, was a member state of the New York Convention. And so the Fifth Circuit here neglects to refer to the Convention and FAA Chapter Two as sources of principles governing the enforceability of the parties’ contractual choice of Caracas as the seat of arbitration.
Article II (3) of the Convention states that “(t)he court of a contracting state, when seized of an action in a matter in respect of which the parties have made an agreement within the meaning of this article, shall, at the request of one of the parties, refer the parties to arbitration, unless it finds that the agreement is null and void, inoperative, or incapable of being performed. ”
The text of Article II (3) raises several issues that arise when, as in Northrop Grumman, a foreign party’s motion to compel arbitration is opposed on the basis that the agreed seat of arbitration is an unreasonable forum in view of political instability.
First, the plain meaning of Article II (3) would appear to permit a court to deny a motion to compel arbitration only if it may find that the agreement to arbitrate, and not merely the agreement on the seat of arbitration, is “null and void” or “incapable of being performed.” The answer to that question may depend on whether the agreement on the seat is viewed as separate and severable from, or completely integral to, the agreement to arbitrate. And the answer to that question cannot be ascertained until a court first decides what law is applicable to interpretation of the arbitration/forum selection clause.
The contract at issue in Northrop Grumman, between a US company and an instrumentality of Venezuelan Government, providing for arbitration in Caracas and (one may infer) application of Venezuelan law to the merits of disputes, seems an unlikely candidate for application of American contract law principles to determine the validity of the agreement to arbitrate. Yet the Fifth Circuit’s decision appears to assume that American contract law principles govern the question of whether the clause may be denied enforcement in whole or in part. Under potentially applicable transnational principles, the nearest analogs to common law doctrines of “impossibility” and “commercial impracticability” might not lead to the same conclusions as would be reached if American law were applied.
A second evident limitation on the power of a District Court is Section 206 of the FAA. That section provides: “A court having jurisdiction under this chapter may direct that arbitration be held in accordance with the agreement at any place therein provided for . . . .” The plain meaning of this provision would seem to negate the possibility of a District Court acting, in a Convention case, to compel arbitration at a place other than the agreed place, or to compel arbitration without reference to any place of arbitration if a place has been designated in the contract.
If these provisions, and the law applicable to interpret the arbitration/forum clause, lead to the conclusion that the clause must be enforced as written, is the aggrieved party without recourse? Not necessarily. If the forum clause is severable, the arbitral tribunal will have jurisdiction to interpret it. And the arbitral tribunal could hear and determine a preliminary contention that the place of arbitration designated in the contract has ceased to exist as a result of dramatically changed political conditions. If that determination is made, the agreement would stand, in its “reformed” state, as if no place of arbitration had ever been selected, and the authority competent to select a place of arbitration in the absence of agreement could select a seat.
Arbitration practitioners should watch with interest to see if the federal district court in Mississippi, on remand in the Northrop Grumman case, takes into account the relevant provisions of the Convention and Chapter Two of the FAA.